teenage friends vanished exploring an old railroad tunnel.

Seven years later, a camera saw them inside.

The summer of 2018 was supposed to be the summer Josh Brennan and Liam Carter would never forget.

They were both 16 years old, best friends since the third grade, growing up in the quiet town of Grafton, West Virginia, a place where not much ever happened.

Grafton was the kind of town where everyone knew everyone, where Friday night meant football games at the high school, and where teenagers spent their summers wandering the woods, swimming in the creek, and looking for something, anything, to break the monotony.

That year, Josh and Liam decided they wanted adventure.

They wanted to explore.

And they found exactly what they were looking for, the old Thornton Tunnel.

The Thornton Tunnel was a relic from another era.

Built in the early 1900s by the Baltimore and Ohio Railroad, it had once been a vital artery for coal trains cutting through the Appalachian Hills.

But by the 1980s, the line had been abandoned.

The tracks were pulled up, the tunnel entrance chained off, and over the decades, nature slowly reclaimed what man had left behind.

Vines crept over the stone archway.

Graffiti covered the walls near the entrance.

Locals told stories about the tunnel.

Some said it was haunted.

Others warned that the structure was unstable, that sections had collapsed deep inside.

Parents told their kids to stay away, which of course made it irresistible to teenagers.

Josh and Liam had heard about the tunnel from older kids at school.

There were rumors that people had walked all the way through it, emerging on the other side nearly 2 mi later.

Some said there were old train cars still sitting inside, frozen in time.

Others claimed they’d seen strange lights flickering deep in the darkness.

Whether any of it was true didn’t matter.

The tunnel represented mystery, danger, freedom, all the things 16-year-olds crave.

So on the afternoon of July 14th, 2018, Josh and Liam packed their backpacks with flashlights, water bottles, snacks, and a portable phone charger.

They told Josh’s mom they were going hiking.

They didn’t mention the tunnel.

They arrived at the entrance just after 2:00 p.m.

The day was hot and humid, typical for a West Virginia summer.

Cicadas buzzed in the trees.

The air smelled like pine and earth.

The tunnel entrance loomed before them.

A dark gaping mouth in the hillside about 20 ft high and 15 ft wide, framed by crumbling stone and rusted iron.

A heavy chain hung across the opening, but it was easy enough to duck under.

Josh went first, turning on his flashlight as he stepped into the cool darkness.

Liam followed close behind, his own flashlight beam cutting through the gloom.

Before we go any further into this story, I want to take a moment to thank you for being here.

If you’re enjoying this mystery and want to see more stories like this one, please consider subscribing to the channel and hitting that notification bell.

Your support means everything and it helps us bring you more incredible immersive true crime and mystery content.

Now, let’s continue.

Inside, the temperature dropped immediately.

The sunlight from the entrance faded within 50 ft, replaced by an oppressive, damp darkness.

The walls were lined with old brick, slick with moisture.

The ground was uneven, littered with rocks, broken glass, and debris.

Water dripped somewhere in the distance, echoing in the silence.

Josh and Liam exchanged a glance, half excitement, half nervousness, and pressed on.

For the first few hundred yards, the tunnel was relatively intact.

They walked side by side, their flashlights sweeping over the walls, illuminating decades old graffiti, rusted bolts, and patches of moss.

They talked in low voices, their words bouncing off the stone.

Liam filmed short clips on his phone, narrating their journey like they were explorers on some grand expedition.

“We’re about a quarter mile in now,” he whispered into the camera, his voice tinged with exhilaration.

Still no sign of any train cars.

But man, this place is creepy.

And as they ventured deeper, the tunnel began to change.

The walls became rougher, more uneven.

In some places, sections of brick had collapsed, leaving jagged holes that opened into smaller side passages, maintenance shafts perhaps, or drainage tunnels.

The air grew colder, heavier.

The silence was profound, broken only by the sound of their footsteps and the occasional drip of water.

Josh’s flashlight flickered once, and his heart jumped.

“Batteries okay?” Liam asked.

Josh checked.

“Yeah, we’re good,” they continued.

After what felt like an hour, though it was hard to judge time in the darkness, they reached a spot where the tunnel widened slightly.

There, off to the side, they saw something that made them both stop.

It was an old wooden door, half rotted, set into the brick wall.

The door hung open on broken hinges, revealing a narrow corridor beyond.

“What do you think that is?” Liam asked, shining his light inside.

“Probably just a maintenance room or something,” Josh replied.

But curiosity got the better of them.

They stepped through the doorway.

The corridor was short, maybe 20 ft long, and led to a small chamber.

Inside, they found remnants of the tunnel’s past.

Old tools, a rusted lantern, a wooden crate filled with metal spikes.

Graffiti covered the walls here, too, though it looked older, faded.

Liam filmed it all.

“This is awesome,” he said, grinning.

They spent a few minutes exploring the chamber, taking photos, imagining the workers who had once used this space.

Then they returned to the main tunnel and kept walking.

By now they had been inside for well over an hour.

The entrance was far behind them, invisible in the darkness.

Their flashlights were the only source of light.

Two narrow beams cutting through an ocean of black.

Josh began to feel a creeping sense of unease.

The tunnel seemed endless.

The walls pressed in.

The silence felt alive, almost watching.

How much farther do you think it is? He asked.

Liam checked his phone.

No signal, of course.

I don’t know.

Maybe another mile.

They pressed on.

The ground became more treacherous, cluttered with larger rocks and debris.

At one point, they had to climb over a section where the ceiling had partially collapsed, forming a jagged pile of stone and brick.

Josh’s foot slipped, and he scraped his hand on the rough surface.

He hissed in pain, examining the cut by flashlight.

It wasn’t deep, but it bled.

Liam handed him a tissue.

“You good?” Josh nodded.

“Yeah, let’s keep going.” But as they moved forward, something changed.

The tunnel, which had been relatively straight up to this point, began to curve.

And then, without warning, they encountered something neither of them had expected.

A fork in the path.

The main tunnel continued straight ahead, but to the left another passage branched off, narrower, darker, sloping slightly downward.

They stood at the junction, shining their lights down both paths.

Which way? Liam asked.

Josh hesitated.

I don’t know.

The main tunnel, I guess.

But Liam was already edging toward the side passage.

His curiosity peaked.

Let’s just check it out real quick.

5 minutes.

Josh didn’t like it.

Something about the side passage felt wrong.

It was narrower, the air colder, the darkness deeper, but Liam was already several steps in, his flashlight beam disappearing around a bend.

Josh sighed and followed.

They walked down the side passage for maybe 2 or 3 minutes.

The walls here were rougher, less finished, as if this section had been carved hastily or abandoned before completion.

The ground sloped downward at a noticeable angle and then suddenly Liam’s flashlight flickered.

Then Josh’s.

Then both went out.

They were plunged into absolute darkness.

Josh.

Liam’s voice was tight, edged with panic.

Yeah, I’m here.

Josh fumbled with his flashlight, shaking it, hitting the side.

Nothing.

Batteries are dead, he said, his own voice shaking.

Liam tried his phone’s flashlight.

It wouldn’t turn on.

Mine, too.

They stood in the darkness, breathing hard, the weight of the earth pressing down on them from all sides.

Josh’s mind raced.

They had backup batteries in the backpack.

He reached for it, unzipping it by feel, his hands trembling.

He found the batteries, tried to replace them in his flashlight, but in the pitch black, it was nearly impossible.

He dropped one.

It clattered away into the darkness, lost.

“Liam, we need to go back,” Josh said, his voice barely a whisper.

“Now I know,” Liam replied.

“Let’s just” And then they heard it.

A sound, faint, distant, echoing from somewhere deeper in the side passage.

A scraping sound, metal on stone, slow, deliberate.

They froze.

The sound stopped.

Silence returned, heavier than before.

We’re leaving,” Josh said.

And this time, there was no argument.

They turned, groping along the wall, moving as quickly as they dared in the darkness.

Josh’s heart hammered in his chest.

Every step felt like it took an eternity.

And then, finally, he saw it, a faint gray light ahead, the junction, the main tunnel.

They stumbled back into the main passage, relief flooding through them.

Liam fumbled with his phone again and this time the flashlight came on.

Weak but enough.

Josh managed to get his flashlight working too.

They didn’t speak.

They just ran.

But somewhere in the panic, in the darkness, in the rush to escape, they made a mistake.

When they reached the fork again, disoriented and terrified, they chose the wrong path.

And that was the last time anyone saw Josh Brennan and Liam Carter alive.

Josh’s mother, Carolyn Brennan, expected the boys home by dinner.

It was a rule she’d always been firm about.

Be home by 6, no exceptions.

Josh was usually good about it.

He’d text if he was running late, call if plans changed.

But that evening, 6:00 came and went, then seven, then 8.

Caroline tried calling Josh’s phone.

It rang and rang, then went to voicemail.

She called again.

Same result.

A knot of worry began to form in her stomach.

At 8:30 p.m., she called Liam’s house.

Diane Carter, Liam’s mother, answered on the second ring.

“Hi, Diane.

It’s Caroline.

Are the boys still at your place?” There was a pause.

“No,” Diane said slowly.

“I thought they were with you.” The knot in Caroline’s stomach tightened.

Josh said they were going hiking this afternoon.

I assumed Liam was with him.

Another pause, longer this time.

Liam told me the same thing, that they were hiking.

He said they’d be back by dinner.

The two mothers stayed on the phone comparing notes, their voices rising with each unanswered question.

Where exactly had the boys gone hiking? Which trail? Why weren’t they answering their phones? Caroline tried calling Josh again.

Nothing.

Diane tried Liam.

Straight to voicemail.

By 9:00 p.m., both families had made the decision to call the police.

The Grafton Police Department dispatched Officer Mark Sullivan to the Brennan residence.

He arrived at 9:20 p.m., notebook in hand, his expression calm but serious.

He asked the standard questions.

When did you last see them? What were they wearing? Did they mention where they were going specifically? Caroline explained that Josh had said they were going hiking, but he hadn’t mentioned a specific location.

Officer Sullivan nodded, writing it all down.

Do the boys have any favorite spots, places they like to go? Caroline thought for a moment.

They used to go to the creek sometimes or the trails behind the high school.

But honestly, they could be anywhere.

There are woods all around here.

Officer Sullivan asked for recent photos of both boys, descriptions of their clothing, any identifying features.

He radioed the information to the station, and within the hour, a search was organized.

Off-dyers were called in.

Volunteers from the community began to gather.

By 1000 p.m., search teams with flashlights were combing the most popular trails around Grafton.

But they found nothing.

No sign of the boys.

No discarded backpacks, no footprints, no clues.

The night stretched on.

Caroline and Diane waited at the Brennan house, clutching cups of coffee they didn’t drink, staring at their phones, praying for a call, a text, anything.

The hours crawled by.

Midnight came and went, then 1:00 a.m.

Then 2:00 a.m.

Still nothing.

As dawn broke on July 15th, the search expanded.

More volunteers arrived.

neighbors, teachers, kids from school, people who had known Josh and Liam their whole lives.

The police brought in search dogs.

Helicopters from the state police were dispatched to scan the surrounding forest from above.

And that’s when someone mentioned the tunnel.

It was one of the boys classmates, a kid named Tyler Hodgej, who brought it up.

He’d heard Josh and Liam talking about the Thornton Tunnel a few weeks earlier, joking about exploring it.

Tyler hadn’t thought much of it at the time.

Everyone talked about the tunnel, but not many people actually went inside.

But now, with the boys missing, it seemed worth mentioning, he told officer Sullivan, who immediately radioed the information to the search coordinator.

By 8:00 a.m., a team was dispatched to the tunnel entrance.

They found it exactly as Tyler had described, the chain across the opening, the graffiti, the dark mouth leading into the hillside.

And there, near the entrance, they found something that made everyone’s blood run cold.

Fresh footprints in the soft earth.

Two sets, teenage sized leading into the tunnel.

Officer Sullivan stood at the entrance, staring into the darkness.

The tunnel stretched away into nothingness, swallowing light, sound, hope.

He radioed for backup, for more equipment.

Within the hour, a full search and rescue team had assembled.

officers, firefighters, paramedics, volunteers with caving experience.

They geared up with helmets, powerful flashlights, radios, and rope.

At 10:00 a.m., they entered the tunnel.

The search team moved methodically, sweeping their lights over every surface, calling out the boys names.

Josh, Liam, can you hear us? Their voices echoed endlessly, bouncing off the brick walls, fading into the distance.

They walked for what felt like miles, checking every side passage, every collapsed section, every shadowy corner.

The tunnel was vast, far longer than most people realized, and it was dangerous.

In several places, the ceiling had caved in, leaving unstable piles of rubble.

In others, the floor dropped away into deep pits filled with stagnant water.

After 3 hours, they reached the fork, the place where the main tunnel branched off into the narrower side passage.

The team split up.

Half continued down the main tunnel.

The other half ventured into the side passage, and that’s where they found the first real clue.

About a/4 mile down the side passage, wedged between two rocks, they found a flashlight.

It was black, heavyduty, the kind you’d buy at a hardware store.

The batteries were dead.

One of the rescue workers picked it up carefully, turning it over in his hands.

There was a piece of tape on the side with the name written in marker.

Josh.

The discovery sent a jolt of adrenaline through the team.

They were on the right track.

The boys had been here, but where were they now? The team pressed deeper into the side passage, their calls growing more urgent.

Josh, Liam, if you can hear us, make a sound.

Anything.

But there was no response.

only silence.

The side passage grew narrower, more treacherous.

In some places, the team had to crawl on their hands and knees, squeezing through gaps barely wide enough for a person.

The air was thick, hard to breathe.

And then, suddenly, the passage ended.

It simply stopped, terminating in a solid wall of collapsed rock and earth.

A dead end.

The rescue workers stared at the wall, confusion and dread settling over them.

The boys had come this way.

The flashlight proved it.

But the passage went nowhere.

There was no way out.

So where were Josh and Liam? One of the rescuers, a firefighter named Dave Kowalsski with years of experience in confined space rescue, examined the collapse section carefully.

He ran his hands over the rocks, testing their stability.

And then he noticed something.

There was a gap, small, barely visible near the bottom of the pile.

Air was moving through it.

He could feel it, a faint current, cool and damp.

There’s something behind this, he said.

Another passage, maybe.

Or a chamber.

The team worked quickly, carefully removing rocks from the pile, widening the gap.

It was slow, dangerous work.

One wrong move could trigger another collapse.

But after nearly an hour, they had created an opening just large enough for a person to squeeze through.

Dave volunteered to go first.

He wriggled through the gap, his helmet light cutting through the darkness on the other side.

He found himself in a small chamber, roughly circular, maybe 15 ft across.

The walls were rough hune, unfinished.

The floor was covered in loose stone and dirt.

And there in the center of the chamber, he saw something that made his heart sink.

A backpack, blue with reflective strips.

He picked it up, unzipped it.

Inside were water bottles, snacks, a portable phone charger, and a wallet.

He opened the wallet.

The driver’s permit inside bore the name Liam Carter, and a photo of a smiling teenage boy.

Dave radioed back to the team.

I found Liam’s backpack, but there’s no sign of them.

He swept his light around the chamber, searching for any other clues, any indication of where the boys might have gone.

And then he saw it, another opening on the far side of the chamber, smaller than the one he’d come through, but passable.

He moved toward it, shining his light inside.

The passage sloped downward sharply, disappearing into darkness.

There’s another passage here, Dave radioed.

It goes down.

I’m going to check it out.

He squeezed through the opening and began to descend.

The passage was steep, slippery, the walls pressing in on both sides.

He moved carefully, testing each step, and then, without warning, his foot slipped.

He slid several feet, rocks clattering around him before he managed to stop himself.

His heart pounded.

He looked down.

The passage continued, dropping into what looked like a vertical shaft.

Dave radioed back.

It’s too dangerous.

I can’t go any farther without proper equipment.

We need climbing gear harnesses.

This could go down for 100 ft or more.

The decision was made to pull back, regroup, and return with specialized equipment.

The team retreated from the tunnel, emerging into daylight at 400 p.m.

They had been inside for 6 hours.

Outside, Caroline and Diane were waiting, surrounded by reporters, neighbors, and police.

When Officer Sullivan approached them, his expression said everything.

“We found some of their belongings,” he said gently.

“But we haven’t found the boys yet.” Caroline’s legs buckled.

Diane caught her and the two women clung to each other sobbing.

The story hit the local news that evening.

By the next morning, it was national.

Two teenage boys missing an abandoned railroad tunnel.

The images were haunting.

The dark entrance.

The search teams emerging with grim faces.

The mothers pleading for information.

The community of Grafton rallied.

Hundreds of volunteers showed up to help with the search.

donations poured in.

But despite the efforts, despite the specialized teams with climbing gear and advanced equipment who descended into the deeper passages, despite the dogs and the helicopters and the endless hours of searching, Josh Brennan and Liam Carter were nowhere to be found.

After 2 weeks, the official search was called off.

The tunnel had been explored as thoroughly as possible.

Every accessible passage had been checked, every chamber investigated.

But the tunnel was vast with countless side passages, many of them collapsed or flooded.

The truth was inescapable.

The boys were gone.

Whether they had fallen into one of the deep shafts, become trapped in a collapsed section, or simply lost their way and succumbed to the elements, no one knew.

Their bodies were never recovered.

The tunnel entrance was sealed with concrete and steel.

Warning signs were posted.

The town of Grafton mourned, and Caroline Brennan and Diane Carter were left with nothing but grief, unanswered questions, and the unbearable weight of not knowing.

The weeks following the disappearance of Josh Brennan and Liam Carter were a blur of desperate activity, crushing hope, and devastating disappointment.

Grafton, a town of barely 5,000 people, had never experienced anything like this.

Missing persons cases were rare here.

Deaths were usually accidents or old age, but two teenage boys vanishing into a tunnel, leaving behind only scattered belongings and unanswered questions.

It was the kind of thing that happened in movies, not in real life.

Yet here it was unfolding in their quiet West Virginia town, and no one knew what to do.

Carolyn Brennan stopped sleeping.

She spent her night sitting in Josh’s room, surrounded by his things, his baseball trophies, his school yearbooks, the acoustic guitar he’d been learning to play.

She’d pick up his shirts, press them to her face, breathe in the fading scent of him.

During the day, she drove to the tunnel site, even though it was sealed, even though the police had told her there was nothing more to be done.

She’d stand there staring at the concrete barrier, willing it to open, willing her son to walk out.

Sometimes other parents from the town would find her there and gently lead her back to her car.

Diane Carter threw herself into action.

She couldn’t sit still, couldn’t accept the official conclusion that the boys were gone.

She organized search parties that scoured the woods around the tunnel, thinking maybe, just maybe, the boys had found another exit.

had emerged somewhere else, injured and disoriented.

She created a Facebook page, Find Josh and Liam.

It gained 10,000 followers in the first week.

She printed flyers with their photos and plastered them across three counties.

She called the local news stations daily, begging them to keep the story alive to keep people looking.

“They’re out there somewhere,” she’d say, her voice from crying.

“I know they are.

We just have to find them.” The media attention was intense at first.

National news outlets descended on Grafton, CNN, Fox News, NBC.

They all sent crews.

The story had everything.

Teenage adventure gone wrong, a mysterious abandoned tunnel, grieving mothers, a small town in crisis.

For 2 weeks, Grafton was the center of the media universe.

Reporters interviewed everyone, classmates, teachers, neighbors, anyone who had ever known the boys.

They filmed inside the tunnel entrance before it was sealed.

Their camera lights illuminating the graffiti covered walls and the darkness beyond.

They brought in experts, cave rescue specialists, psychologists, criminologists who speculated on what might have happened.

Some theories were grounded in reality.

The most common was that the boys had gotten lost in the labyrinth of passages.

Their flashlights had died, and they’d fallen into one of the deep vertical shafts or become trapped in a collapsed section.

It was tragic, but it made sense.

The tunnel was inherently dangerous, a death trap for anyone who ventured too far, unprepared.

Other theories were less plausible.

Some people suggested the boys had run away, staged their own disappearance.

But those who knew Josh and Liam dismissed that immediately.

They were good kids, close to their families, excited about their futures.

Josh had been planning to try out for the varsity baseball team in the fall.

Liam had just gotten his driver’s license and was saving money for a car.

They had no reason to run.

Then there were the darker theories.

Some locals whispered about foul play, about someone using the tunnel as cover for something sinister, but there was no evidence of that.

No sign of struggle, no indication that anyone else had been involved.

The police investigated thoroughly, interviewing everyone the boys knew, checking their social media, their text messages, their bank accounts.

Everything pointed to a tragic accident, nothing more.

The search efforts continued for the first month, driven by community volunteers even after the official rescue teams pulled back.

A local caving club offered their expertise, exploring deeper sections of the tunnel that the initial rescue teams hadn’t been able to reach.

They repelled down the vertical shaft that Dave Kowolski had found.

Descending nearly 200 ft into the earth, at the bottom, they found a flooded chamber.

the water black and still.

They searched it with underwater lights and probes, but found nothing.

No bodies, no equipment, no clues.

They explored other side passages, crawling through tight squeezes, wading through ankle deep water, breathing stale air through dust masks.

The tunnel system was far more extensive than anyone had realized.

In addition to the main railroad tunnel, there were dozens of smaller passages, drainage tunnels, ventilation shafts, exploratory bors from the original construction.

Some led nowhere, others connected to natural caves in the limestone bedrock.

It was a maze, and every passage they explored raised the same terrifying question.

How far in had the boys gone before they got into trouble? By the end of August 2018, even the most dedicated volunteers had to admit defeat.

They had searched every accessible part of the tunnel system.

They had climbed, crawled, and repelled through miles of underground passages.

They had used thermal imaging cameras, listening devices, and even cadaavver dogs.

But the tunnel had yielded nothing beyond the flashlight and the backpack.

It was as if Josh and Liam had simply vanished into the earth.

The psychological toll on the families was immense.

Caroline Brennan slipped into a deep depression.

She stopped going to work, stopped answering the phone, stopped leaving the house except to visit the tunnel site.

Her husband Robert tried to hold things together, but he was struggling too.

He’d always been the strong one, the problem solver, but this was a problem with no solution.

He’d lie awake at night, imagining his son’s final moments, scared, alone, trapped in the dark.

The not knowing was the worst part.

If they’d found bodies, there would at least be closure.

But this limbo, this uncertainty was torture.

Diane Carter channeled her grief differently.

She became obsessed with finding answers.

She hired a private investigator, a former state trooper named Gary Melton, who had experience with missing person’s cases.

Gary reviewed all the evidence, re-interviewed witnesses, and even entered the tunnel himself with a small team.

But he came to the same conclusion as everyone else.

The boys had gotten lost, gone too deep, and met with some kind of accident.

“I’m sorry,” he told Diane after 3 weeks of investigation.

But there’s nothing more I can do.

The tunnel is just too vast, too unstable.

If they’re in there, they’re in a place we can’t reach.

Diane refused to accept it.

She contacted other experts, geologists, engineers, anyone who might have insight into the tunnel structure.

She obtained old blueprints from the railroad company, hoping they might reveal passages the search teams had missed.

She studied them obsessively, marking possible routes, calculating distances.

But the blueprints were incomplete, handdrawn sketches from over a century ago, and many of the passages they showed no longer existed or had been altered by collapses and flooding.

The community tried to move on, but it was difficult.

The high school held a memorial service at the start of the fall semester.

Josh and Liam’s empty desks became shrines covered with flowers, photos, and handwritten notes from their classmates.

The baseball team wore special patches with the boys initials.

The local church held weekly prayer vigils.

But as September turned to October, and October turned to November, the crowds at the vigils grew smaller.

The news crews left.

The Facebook posts became less frequent.

Life relentlessly continued.

For Caroline and Diane, though, there was no moving on.

They formed a bond forged in shared grief, speaking on the phone every day, sometimes for hours.

They talked about their sons, shared memories, cried together.

They also shared a stubborn, irrational hope that somehow someway the boys would come back.

Maybe they found a way out, Caroline would say.

Maybe they’re hurt somewhere with amnesia and they just don’t know who they are.

Diane would agree.

Even though both of them knew how unlikely that was, the hope was all they had left.

By December 2018, 6 months after the disappearance, even that hope was fading.

The FBI had closed their investigation, finding no evidence of foul play or federal crimes.

The state police had moved on to other cases.

The tunnel remained sealed.

a concrete tombstone marking the place where two young lives had ended.

Grafton settled into a somber new normal.

The kind of quiet that comes after tragedy when people stop talking about what happened because it hurts too much to remember.

Josh’s and Liam’s families held a joint memorial service on the six-month anniversary of their disappearance.

It was held at the Grafton Community Center and hundreds of people attended.

There were photo displays showing the boys at various ages playing little league, goofing around at birthday parties, smiling in school pictures.

There were speeches from teachers, coaches, and friends.

“Caroline and Diane both spoke, their voices breaking as they shared stories about their sons.” “Josh was kind,” Caroline said through tears.

“He was always the first one to help someone who was struggling.

He saw the good in everyone.” Diane spoke about Liam’s sense of adventure, his curiosity, his bright future.

He wanted to be an engineer, she said.

He wanted to build things to make the world better.

And now we’ll never know what he could have become.

The service ended with the release of biodegradable balloons, 100 of them, floating up into the gray winter sky.

People stood in the parking lot, watching until the balloons disappeared from sight.

tiny dots of color against the clouds.

And then slowly they dispersed, returning to their lives, their routines, their own families.

The case of Josh Brennan and Liam Carter was closed.

Not solved, but closed.

The boys were gone, lost somewhere in the dark beneath the hills, and there was nothing more anyone could do except remember and wait.

Because sometimes, even in the deepest darkness, even after years of silence, the truth has a way of coming back to the light.

But for now, in the winter of 2018, there was only grief and questions and the unbearable weight of not knowing.

Caroline returned to Josh’s room.

Diane returned to her search efforts, and Grafton tried to heal from a wound that would never fully close.

The tunnel sat silent, sealed, keeping its secrets.

And somewhere deep in the earth, in passages no one had reached, Josh and Liam remained, waiting, perhaps to be found, or perhaps already at peace, in a place beyond the reach of flashlights and rescue teams, and the desperate prayers of those who loved them.

Time is a strange thing when you lose someone without closure.

For most people, it moves forward steadily, carrying them through seasons and years, through changes and new beginnings.

But for Caroline Brennan and Diane Carter, time became something else entirely.

It became a wait, a presence, a relentless reminder that their sons were gone, and that with each passing day, the chances of finding them, alive or dead, grew smaller.

The first year was the hardest.

Every holiday, every birthday, every milestone that Josh and Liam should have experienced became an open wound.

In the fall of 2018, Josh should have been trying out for varsity baseball.

Instead, Caroline sat in the empty bleachers during tryyouts, watching other boys run the bases, feeling the absence like a physical pain.

In the spring of 2019, Liam should have been at prom, nervous in a rented tuxedo, taking photos with his date.

Instead, Diane stayed home that night, curtains drawn, unable to bear the sight of teenagers celebrating when her son never would.

The second year brought a different kind of pain, the realization that life was continuing without them.

Josh’s class graduated in June 2020.

Caroline couldn’t bring herself to attend the ceremony, but Diane did.

She sat in the back row of the football stadium, watching kids in caps and gowns receive their diplomas.

And when they reached the L’s in the alphabet, when they should have called Liam Carter’s name, there was only silence.

The principal had offered to include a memorial moment, but Diane had declined.

She didn’t want sympathy.

She wanted her son.

By the third year, 2021, something shifted.

The acute grief gave way to something more chronic, more manageable, but no less painful.

Caroline returned to work, though she often found herself staring blankly at her computer screen.

Unable to focus, Robert Brennan started attending a support group for parents of missing children, meeting once a month in a church basement with others who understood the unique torture of not knowing.

Diane continued her advocacy work, though the Facebook page had become quieter, the updates less frequent.

She’d post on significant dates.

Josh’s birthday, Liam’s birthday, the anniversary of their disappearance.

But the engagement had dropped.

People had moved on.

The boys were becoming a memory, a tragedy, a cautionary tale about the dangers of abandoned places.

The police department kept the case file open technically, but no new leads emerged.

Every few months, someone would call in a tip.

A hitchhiker spotted on a highway who looked like one of the boys.

A sighting at a gas station three states away.

Each time Caroline’s heart would leap with hope.

Each time the tip would lead nowhere.

The hitchhiker would be someone else.

The gas station footage too grainy to confirm anything.

False hope, Caroline learned, was worse than no hope at all.

In 2022, 4 years after the disappearance, a true crime podcast called Vanished devoted a threeep episode series to the case.

The podcast hosts interviewed Caroline, Diane, former search team members, and classmates of the boys.

They explored various theories, analyzed the evidence, and invited listeners to submit their own ideas about what might have happened.

The episodes got over a million downloads.

For a few weeks, the case was back in the public consciousness.

The Facebook page saw a surge in activity.

Amateur sleuths debated theories in online forums, but ultimately the podcast couldn’t answer the central question, “Where were Josh and Liam?” And after the series ended, the attention faded once more.

Diane took some comfort in the podcast, at least people remembered.

At least her son’s story was being told.

But Caroline found it invasive, painful, hearing strangers speculate about Josh’s final moments, reducing her son’s life to a mystery to be solved for entertainment.

It felt wrong.

She stopped listening after the first episode.

By 2023, 5 years after the boys vanished, Grafton had changed.

New families had moved to town.

Kids who’d been in elementary school when Josh and Liam disappeared were now in high school themselves.

The memorial garden that the town had built near the high school, a small plot with a bench and a plaque bearing the boy’s names, had become just another feature of the landscape, noticed mainly by those who had known them.

The tragedy was becoming history.

But for Caroline and Diane, there was no moving forward.

Their homes remained shrines.

Josh’s room stayed exactly as he’d left it.

Bed unmade, posters on the walls, sneakers by the door.

Liam’s room was the same.

Clothes still in the closet, books still on the shelves, everything waiting for a boy who would never return.

Their husbands had suggested gently that maybe it was time to pack some things away, to create some space to breathe, but both women refused.

Not until we know, Caroline said.

Not until we have answers.

The marriage casualties were perhaps inevitable.

Robert Brennan tried.

He really did.

But by late 2023, he couldn’t live in the moraleum their home had become.

He moved out, not divorcing Caroline, but separating, needing distance from the grief that consumed her.

They still talked, still cared for each other, but they were surviving in different ways, and those ways were no longer compatible.

Dian’s husband, Michael, lasted longer.

But by early 2024, he too needed space.

The separation was amicable.

sad.

The result of two people who loved each other but could no longer bear the weight of shared grief.

The sixth anniversary in July 2024 was quiet.

No media coverage, no vigils, just Caroline and Diane meeting at the coffee shop in town, sitting across from each other, drinking lukewarm coffee and talking about their sons as if they’d just seen them yesterday.

Josh would be 22 now.

Caroline said, her voice distant.

He’d probably be in college.

Maybe studying sports medicine.

He always loved helping people.

Diane nodded.

Liam would be finishing his engineering degree.

He’d have an internship somewhere, building something incredible.

They smiled at these imagined futures, knowing they were fantasies, knowing their sons would be forever 16, frozen in time.

But something changed in the fall of 2024.

The tunnel, which had remained sealed for over 6 years, became the subject of new interest, not from search teams or grieving families, but from the state government.

West Virginia was investing in infrastructure, and part of that investment included assessing old railroad tunnels for potential renovation and reuse.

The Thornton Tunnel was on the list.

Engineers needed to survey it, determine its structural integrity, and decide whether it could be repurposed as part of a rail trail project that would convert abandoned rail lines into hiking and biking paths.

When Diane heard about this, she saw an opportunity.

She contacted the state transportation department, the engineering firm hired for the project, anyone who would listen.

Please, she begged.

If you’re going in there anyway, if you’re surveying the tunnel, please look for my son.

Please look for any sign of them.

The engineers were sympathetic but non-committal.

Their job was structural assessment, not search and rescue, but they agreed to keep an eye out, to document anything unusual they found.

The survey work began in November 2024.

The concrete seal at the tunnel entrance was removed and for the first time in 6 years, the darkness beyond was exposed to daylight.

The engineering team entered with modern equipment, drones, 3D mapping scanners, highintensity LED lights.

Their goal was to map the entire tunnel system, identify structural weaknesses, and generate a comprehensive report.

But they quickly realized the job was more complicated than anticipated.

The tunnel wasn’t just a single passage.

It was a network of interconnected passages, many of them not on the original blueprints.

The drone operators sent their devices deep into the tunnel, navigating through the main passage and exploring the side tunnels.

The drones transmitted live video feeds back to laptops set up at the entrance where engineers watched the footage, taking notes, marking areas of concern.

And then on a cold afternoon in late January 2025, 7 years and 6 months after Josh Brennan and Liam Carter had walked into the tunnel and never walked out, one of the drones found something.

It was flying through a section of the tunnel nearly a mile and a half from the entrance in an area that had never been fully explored during the original search.

The passage here was narrow, unstable, with large sections of collapsed ceiling creating obstacles.

The drone navigated carefully, its camera sweeping across the walls, the floor, the rubble, and then in the beam of its LED light.

It captured something that made the engineer monitoring the feed freeze movement.

At first, he thought it was a trick of the light, a shadow, a reflection.

He rewound the footage, watched it again.

there, definite movement, something shifting in the darkness.

He called over his supervisor.

They watched together, enhancing the image, zooming in, and what they saw was impossible, inexplicable, terrifying.

Two figures, pale, thin, moving slowly through the darkness.

Human figures inside the tunnel where no one should be, where no one could be.

Where Josh Brennan and Liam Carter had disappeared 7 years ago.

The engineer grabbed his radio, his hands shaking.

We need to call the police, he said, his voice barely a whisper.

Right now.

We need to call them right now because what the camera had seen, what the footage clearly showed was two young men alive moving through the tunnel’s deepest passages.

Two young men who shouldn’t exist.

Two ghosts made flesh.

Two boys who had vanished 7 years ago and who impossibly were still inside, still alive, still there.

The call came into the Grafton Police Department at 3:47 p.m.

on January 23rd, 2025.

The dispatcher, a woman named Linda Chen, who’d been working the desk for 15 years, took the call from James Whitmore, the lead engineer on the tunnel survey project.

His voice was shaking.

You need to send someone to the Thornton Tunnel immediately, he said.

We found something.

We found We think we found people inside.

Linda’s fingers hovered over her keyboard.

“People? What do you mean people?” “Our drone,” James said, struggling to keep his voice steady.

It picked up movement.

“Two figures deep inside the tunnel.” “Human figures.

They’re moving.

They’re alive,” Linda felt her heart skip.

The Thornton tunnel, the Brennan and Carter boys.

Everyone in Grafton knew the story.

“Are you certain? Could it be a malfunction? Something on the lens? We’ve checked and rechecked the footage,” James replied.

“It’s real.

There are two people inside that tunnel, and they shouldn’t be there.

No one’s been in there since we broke the seal 3 months ago, and we’ve had the entrance monitored.

I don’t know how they got in, but they’re there.” Within minutes, Officer Mark Sullivan, the same officer who’d taken the initial missing person’s report 7 years ago, was speeding toward the tunnel site, sirens blaring.

Behind him, a convoy of emergency vehicles followed.

Fire trucks, ambulances, a tactical rescue unit.

The police chief called the state police, who dispatched additional resources.

By 4:30 p.m., the tunnel entrance was swarming with personnel.

“James met Officer Sullivan at the command tent the engineering team had set up.

His laptop was open, the drone footage queued up and ready.

Here,” he said, hitting play.

“Watch this section.” Sullivan leaned in, his eyes fixed on the screen.

The footage showed a narrow passage, the walls closed and rough, debris scattered across the floor.

The drone’s light cut through the darkness, illuminating maybe 20 ft ahead.

And then, at the edge of the light’s reach, something moved.

A figure, humanoid, definitely humanoid, stepping slowly from behind a pile of fallen rock.

Then another figure close behind.

They were pale, their clothes dark and tattered.

They moved with a strange shuffling gate, as if injured or disoriented.

The drone hovered for a few more seconds, capturing the figures as they moved deeper into the shadows, and then the feed ended as the drone returned to base for battery replacement.

Sullivan felt a chill run down his spine.

“How far in is this?” “About a mile and a half from the main entrance,” James said.

in a side passage that branches off from the main tunnel.

It’s a section we haven’t physically accessed yet, too unstable.

That’s why we sent the drone first.

Sullivan radioed the information to the incident commander, Fire Chief Tom Garrett.

Within minutes, a plan was forming.

A rescue team would enter the tunnel, guided by the drone footage and realtime drone surveillance.

They’d attempt to make contact with whoever or whatever was inside.

The team would consist of six members.

Three firefighters with confined space rescue training, two paramedics, and Officer Sullivan himself.

But before they could move, Chief Garrett made another call to Caroline Brennan.

She was at home folding laundry in the living room, the TV playing quietly in the background.

When her phone rang and she saw the police department’s number, her first instinct was irritation.

They only called when there was a false lead.

Another dead end.

She almost didn’t answer, but something made her pick up.

Mrs.

Brennan, this is Chief Garrett.

I need you to sit down.

Caroline’s legs went weak.

She sank onto the couch.

What is it? We’re at the tunnel.

The engineering team found something on their surveillance footage.

Two people inside the tunnel moving.

We don’t know who they are yet, but Mrs.

Brennan, there’s a possibility, a small possibility, that it could be Josh and Liam.

The phone slipped from Caroline’s hand.

She couldn’t breathe, couldn’t think.

7 years.

7 years of grief, of hopelessness, of imagining her son’s body lying cold and broken somewhere in the dark.

And now this.

Impossible.

It had to be impossible.

She picked up the phone with trembling hands.

“Are you sure? Are you absolutely sure?” “We’re not sure of anything yet,” Garrett said gently.

“But we’re sending a team in now.

I wanted you to know.” “And Mrs.

Brennan, I’ve also called Diane Carter.

I think you two should come to the site, just in case.” Caroline didn’t remember the drive to the tunnel.

Diane met her in the parking area and they held each other, neither speaking, both too terrified to hope.

They stood behind the police barricade, watching as the rescue team geared up.

Helmets, radios, medical kits, portable stretchers.

The team entered the tunnel at 5:15 p.m.

Just as the winter sun was beginning to set.

Inside the tunnel, the rescue team moved quickly but carefully.

They had the drone footage on a tablet, using it as a map.

The main tunnel was stable enough, the path clear.

But as they approached the mile and a half mark, where the side passage branched off, the conditions deteriorated.

The walls here showed signs of recent shifting.

Loose rocks littered the ground.

The air was thick with dust.

Watch your step, one of the firefighters, a veteran named Marcus Webb, called out.

This whole section could come down if we’re not careful.

Udin.

They entered the side passage, their lights revealing a narrower, more claustine space.

The passage twisted and turned, and in places they had to climb over or squeeze between fallen debris.

After 10 minutes of navigating, they reached the area where the drone had captured the footage.

Marcus held up his hand, signaling the team to stop.

He called out, his voice echoing in the confined space.

Hello, is anyone there? This is the Grafton Fire Department.

If you can hear us, make a sound.

We’re here to help.

Silence.

Only the distant drip of water and the sound of their own breathing.

They waited, listening.

And then, faintly from somewhere deeper in the passage, they heard it.

A voice, weak horse, barely more than a whisper, but a voice.

Help.

The team exchanged glances, adrenaline surging.

Marcus moved forward, the others following close behind.

They rounded a bend in the passage, and their lights fell upon a sight that would haunt them for the rest of their lives.

Two young men sitting against the tunnel wall.

Their clothes were filthy, torn to rags.

Their faces were gaunt, skeletal, skin stretched tight over bone.

Their hair was long, matted, and unckempt.

Their eyes sunken deep in their sockets, squinted against the sudden brightness of the flashlights.

One of them raised a hand shielding his face.

The other simply stared, his expression vacant, almost uncomprehending.

Marcus approached slowly, crouching down to their level.

“It’s okay,” he said softly.

“We’re here to help.

Can you tell me your names?” The young man, who had raised his hand, lowered it slowly.

His lips moved, forming words that took several attempts to vocalize.

“Josh,” he whispered.

“I’m Josh.” Marcus felt his heart stop.

He looked at the other young man.

“And you?” The second young man blinked slowly as if processing the question took immense effort.

“Liam,” he finally said, his voice cracking.

Marcus keyed his radio, his hand shaking so badly he could barely press the button.

“Garrett, this is Web.

We found them.

We found Josh Brennan and Liam Carter.

They’re alive.

Repeat, they are alive.

Outside the tunnel, Caroline Brennan collapsed.

Diane Carter screamed.

Officers and paramedics rushed to support them as they sobbed, overwhelming relief crashing over them in waves.

Seven years.

Seven impossible years.

And their sons were alive.

Inside the tunnel, the paramedics were already working.

They checked vital signs, inserted IVs, assessed the boys for injuries.

Both were severely dehydrated and malnourished.

Their bodies wasted to almost nothing.

Josh’s weight, the paramedics estimated, was maybe 90 lb.

He’d lost at least 50 lb from his healthy teenage weight.

Liam was in similar condition.

Both had infections, sores covering their skin, and their eyes showed signs of prolonged darkness exposure.

“We need to get them out now,” one of the paramedics, a woman named Rachel Torres, said urgently.

“They’re critical.

I don’t know how they’re even conscious.

The team worked quickly, carefully lifting the boys onto portable stretchers.” Josh and Liam didn’t resist, didn’t speak.

They simply lay there staring up at the ceiling with hollow eyes as if unable to process what was happening.

The journey back through the tunnel took 40 minutes.

The team moving as fast as they dared while carrying the stretchers through the unstable passages.

When they finally emerged from the tunnel entrance at 6:45 p.m.

The scene outside was chaos.

News crews had arrived, their cameras capturing everything.

Crowds of onlookers pressed against the barricades.

And there at the front, held back by officers but straining forward with desperate urgency, were Caroline and Diane.

Josh.

Caroline screamed.

Josh, baby, I’m here.

The stretchers were loaded into waiting ambulances.

Caroline was allowed to climb in with Josh, and she took his hand, tears streaming down her face.

Josh turned his head slowly, looking at her.

For a moment, there was no recognition in his eyes, and then something flickered.

A spark of awareness, of memory.

His lips moved.

“Mom,” he whispered.

Caroline broke down completely, pressing her son’s hand to her face.

“Yes, baby.

Yes, it’s mom.

You’re safe now.

You’re safe.” Diane rode with Liam, experiencing the same heartbreaking moment.

The delayed recognition, the confusion, and then the faint whisper.

Mom.

It was the most beautiful word she’d ever heard.

The ambulances raced to Grafton City Hospital where a trauma team was standing by.

The boys were rushed into separate examination rooms and for the next 3 hours doctors worked to stabilize them.

The preliminary findings were shocking.

Both Josh and Liam were suffering from severe malnutrition, dehydration, multiple infections, muscle atrophy, and what appeared to be early stages of organ failure.

Their teeth showed signs of decay.

Their skin was covered in lesions and fungal infections.

They had lost significant bone density.

It was, in the words of one doctor, as close to death as you can get while still being alive.

But they were alive.

Against all odds, against all logic, they had survived 7 years inside that tunnel.

The question everyone wanted answered, the question that rippled through the hospital, through Grafton, through the nation as news of the rescue spread like wildfire, was simple and yet impossibly complex.

How how had two teenage boys survived for seven years in an abandoned railroad tunnel with no apparent food, no clean water, no light, no contact with the outside world? How had they not died of exposure in the first week? How had they avoided fatal injuries in the unstable passages? How had they maintained even the minimal level of health necessary to still be breathing when the rescue team found them? The doctors had no answers.

The police had no answers.

And Josh and Liam, in their semi-conscious, traumatized state, couldn’t or wouldn’t provide any.

Over the next 48 hours, as the boy’s conditions slowly stabilized, doctors attempted to gather information.

But Josh and Liam were largely unresponsive.

They stared at the ceiling or the walls, rarely making eye contact.

They spoke only in whispers and only when directly questioned.

When asked what had happened, where they’d been, how they’d survived, their answers were fragmented, confusing, often contradictory.

Water, Josh mumbled at one point.

There was water.

We drank the water.

“What did you eat?” the doctor asked gently.

Josh’s eyes grew distant.

“Don’t don’t remember.

Mushrooms, maybe things growing on the walls.” Liam’s account was equally vague.

We walked, he said, kept walking, looking for a way out.

Got lost.

Couldn’t find the entrance anymore.

For 7 years, the doctor pressed.

You were lost for 7 years.

Liam didn’t answer.

He just turned his face to the wall and closed his eyes.

Psychiatrists were brought in.

They diagnosed both boys with severe trauma, possible dissociative amnesia, and what they termed captivity syndrome, a psychological state similar to that experienced by long-term hostages or prisoners, where the mind shuts down non-essential functions to survive unbearable conditions.

But even the psychiatrist couldn’t explain the physical survival.

The human body can’t survive 7 years on mushrooms and stagnant water.

It simply can’t.

And yet here were Josh and Liam alive, breathing, their hearts beating.

By the third day, the media frenzy had reached a fever pitch.

The story was everywhere.

Front page of every major newspaper.

Lead story on every news broadcast.

Trending number one on social media.

Miracle in West Virginia.

Lost boys found alive after 7 years.

Speculation ran wild.

Some claimed divine intervention.

Others suggested the boys had found some hidden cash of supplies left by railroad workers decades ago.

A few conspiracy theorists whispered about government experiments, secret bunkers, cover-ups.

But the truth, whatever it was, remained locked inside the tunnel and inside the minds of two traumatized young men who couldn’t or wouldn’t tell their story.

7 months have passed since Josh Brennan and Liam Carter were pulled from the Thornton Tunnel.

7 months of medical treatment, psychological therapy, police investigations, and media scrutiny.

7 months of a world trying to understand what happened in those seven years of darkness.

And yet, even now, in August 2025, the truth remains frustratingly elusive.

A puzzle with pieces that don’t quite fit.

a story with chapters that make no logical sense.

The physical recovery has been the most straightforward part, though even that has been complicated.

After their initial stabilization at Grafton City Hospital, both Josh and Liam were transferred to the University Hospital in Morgantown, where they spent 3 months under intensive care.

The medical team worked systematically to address their myriad health issues.

Rehydration, nutritional rehabilitation, treatment of infections, dental work, physical therapy to rebuild their atrophied muscles.

Dr.

Patricia Hammond, the lead physician on their case, described their condition as unprecedented in modern medical literature.

We see cases of severe malnutrition in famine victims, hostage situations, cases of extreme neglect, she explained at a press conference in March.

But those cases typically span months, maybe a year or two at most.

What Josh and Liam survived defies standard medical understanding.

By all conventional measures, they should not have survived more than a few weeks in those conditions.

But survive they did.

By April 2025, both young men had gained back significant weight.

Josh was up to 130 lbs, Liam to 140.

They could walk unassisted, though they tired easily.

Their infections had cleared.

Their organ function had largely normalized, though doctors warned there might be long-term complications down the road.

Physically, they were healing.

Psychologically, however, was a different story.

Both Josh and Liam were diagnosed with severe post-traumatic stress disorder, depression, and what psychiatrists called prolonged captivity trauma.

Dr.

Ellen Morowitz, the psychiatrist who has been working with them since their rescue, explained that their mental state was consistent with prisoners of war or long-term kidnapping victims.

They experienced years of isolation, sensory deprivation, constant fear, and physical deprivation.

She said, “The mind creates coping mechanisms to survive that kind of trauma, but those mechanisms often include dissociation, memory suppression, and emotional withdrawal.

The boy’s memories of their time in the tunnel remain fragmented and inconsistent.

In therapy sessions and police interviews conducted gently with psychiatrists present, they’ve provided pieces of their story.

But those pieces are like shards of a shattered mirror, sharp, scattered, reflecting only distorted glimpses of the whole picture.

What investigators have been able to piece together is this.

Josh and Liam entered the tunnel on July 14th, 2018, just as everyone knew.

They ventured deeper than they’d planned.

Their flashlights died and in the darkness and panic they became disoriented.

According to Liam, they tried to find their way back to the entrance.

But in the maze of passages, they took a wrong turn.

Then another and another.

Everything looked the same in the dark, Liam said during one interview, his voice flat, emotionless.

We’d feel our way along the walls, counting steps, trying to remember which way we’d come from.

But we’d end up in places we didn’t recognize, passages that seemed to go on forever.

Josh’s account corroborates this.

We panicked, he admitted.

We were stupid.

We should have stayed in one place, waited for rescue, but we were scared, and we kept moving, thinking we’d find a way out.

And we just got more and more lost.

At some point, neither can say exactly when, as time became meaningless in the darkness, they discovered a section of the tunnel where water seeped through cracks in the walls, collecting in small pools.

The water was cold, mineralheavy, but drinkable.

This, doctors believe, is how they survived the dehydration that should have killed them within days.

As for food, both boys mention finding fungal growths on the tunnel walls, mushrooms, moss, some kind of pale rootlike vegetation growing in the perpetual darkness and dampness.

Whether these were actually edible, or whether the boy’s bodies adapted to digest them through sheer desperation remains unclear.

Micologists brought in to analyze samples from the tunnel found several species of caved dwelling fungi, some of which have minimal nutritional value.

Enough perhaps to sustain life at the barest level, but not enough to thrive.

They essentially entered a state of extreme hibernation metabolism, Dr.

Hammond explained.

Their bodies slowed down, conserving energy, operating at the absolute minimum necessary for survival.

Combined with the cool, constant temperature of the tunnel, around 55° F, and minimal physical activity, they could theoretically survive on far fewer calories than a normal person would need.

A D.

But even with this explanation, the math doesn’t quite add up.

The amount of nutrients the boys could have obtained from cave fungi and mineral water should not have been sufficient for seven years.

Some medical experts have suggested they may have found another food source.

Perhaps insects or even small animals that ventured into the tunnel, though Josh and Liam have never mentioned this, and both have shown visible distress when the topic is raised.

The psychological adaptation is perhaps even more remarkable than the physical one.

Dr.

Morowitz believes that both boys entered what she calls survival mode, a psychological state where higher cognitive functions shut down.

And the brain focuses entirely on immediate survival needs.

They stopped thinking about the future, stopped remembering the past in any detailed way, she explained.

They existed purely in the present moment.

Find water, find food, sleep, wake, repeat.

This kind of mental compartmentalization is actually a protective mechanism.

If they’d maintained full awareness of their situation, the hopelessness, the likelihood they’d never escape, they probably would have given up.

But there are gaps in their accounts, inconsistencies that trouble investigators.

When asked about specific events, how they marked time, how they navigated, whether they ever saw or heard the search teams, both boys become vague, sometimes contradicting themselves or each other.

Josh claims they found a relatively safe chamber where they stayed most of the time, venturing out only to search for water and food.

Liam says they kept moving constantly, never staying in one place for long.

Josh says they talked to each other throughout, keeping each other sane.

Liam says they often went days without speaking.

The darkness and despair making communication feel pointless.

And then there are the stranger elements, the details that don’t fit any rational framework.

During one therapy session, Josh mentioned the lights.

When Dr.

Morowitz pressed him about this, he became agitated.

There were lights sometimes, he insisted.

Not flashlights, different lights, blue lights deep in the tunnel.

We followed them sometimes, but they always disappeared.

Liam has mentioned similar phenomena.

We heard things, too, he said quietly during a police interview.

Voices, not our voices, other voices echoing from far away.

We’d call out, but no one ever answered.

Dr.

Morowitz attributes these experiences to hallucinations common in cases of sensory deprivation and extreme stress.

The brain deprived of external stimuli begins to generate its own.

She explained visual and auditory hallucinations are expected in their situation.

But it doesn’t explain everything.

It doesn’t explain how in a tunnel system that was thoroughly searched by experienced rescue teams with advanced equipment, the boys remained hidden for 7 years.

It doesn’t explain how they survived in sections of the tunnel that were deemed too unstable or too flooded to access.

And it certainly doesn’t explain the most troubling discovery made by investigators when they returned to the tunnel after the rescue.

In the chamber where Josh and Liam were found, searchers discovered several items.

Empty water bottles, dozens of them from brands that didn’t exist 7 years ago.

Rappers from energy bars with production dates from 2023 and 2024.

And perhaps most disturbing, a smartphone dead and water damaged.

But when forensic technicians managed to extract data from it, they found photos, hundreds of photos dated throughout the seven years, showing Josh and Liam at various stages of their ordeal.

The police haven’t released these photos to the public, but those who’ve seen them describe them as haunting.

The boys progressively thinner, paler, more holloweyed, posing in different sections of the tunnel.

Sometimes alone, sometimes together, always in darkness, illuminated only by the phone’s flash.

The metadata showed the photos were taken at irregular intervals, sometimes weeks apart, sometimes months.

The last photo was dated January 20th, 2025, just 3 days before the drone found them.

But here’s the impossible part.

The phone belonged to neither Josh nor Liam.

It was registered to a name neither family recognizes.

And according to the phone’s GPS data, which logged intermittent signals whenever the phone was near the tunnel entrance, the device had exited and re-entered the tunnel multiple times over the seven years.

Someone else was in that tunnel.

Someone who had access to the outside world.

someone who photographed Josh and Liam, possibly provided them with supplies, and then vanished before the rescue team arrived.

The FBI has taken over the investigation, treating it now as a potential kidnapping or confinement case.

They’ve analyzed the phone records, traced the registered owner, who turned out to be a false identity, and interviewed everyone who worked on the tunnel survey project, but they found no suspects, no clear motive, no explanation.

Josh and Liam, when asked about the phone, about the photos, about the possibility of another person in the tunnel, become silent.

Their expressions close off.

We don’t remember, they say.

or simply we were alone.

Dr.

Morowit suggests they may be protecting someone either out of fear or because of some form of Stockholm syndrome or perhaps their memories are genuinely too fragmented to recall.

Trauma does strange things to memory.

She says they may have repressed experiences that were too threatening to process.

As of August 2025, Josh and Liam are living with their mothers in Grafton, slowly reintegrating into a world that has moved on without them.

They’re both enrolled in online education programs, working toward their high school diplomas.

They attend therapy three times a week.

They avoid media attention, rarely leaving their homes.

They’re alive, but in many ways they’re still trapped.

Not in the tunnel, but in the shadows it left inside them.

The Thornton tunnel has been sealed once again.

This time with reinforced barriers and 24-hour surveillance.

The engineering survey project was cancelled.

No one wants to go back in there.

Not after what was found.

Not after the questions that remain unanswered.

Caroline and Diane are grateful.

Profoundly.

overwhelmingly grateful to have their sons back.

But they also know they didn’t get back the boys who disappeared 7 years ago.

Those boys are gone.

What they have now are two young men who’ve seen and experienced something that has fundamentally changed them, something they may never fully understand or share.

The case remains open.

The investigation continues.

And somewhere in the depths of the Thornton tunnel, in passages that have never been fully explored, secrets still wait in the darkness.

There are some stories that don’t have clean endings.

Some mysteries that resist resolution, no matter how hard we search for answers.

The case of Josh Brennan and Liam Carter is one of those stories.

A tale that challenges everything we think we know about survival, about human endurance, about the boundaries between the possible and the impossible.

As autumn approaches in 2025, life in Grafton continues.

The leaves are beginning to turn gold and red on the hillsides.

Friday night football has returned to the high school stadium.

The coffee shop on Main Street still serves the same mediocre coffee it always has.

On the surface, everything looks normal.

But beneath that surface, the town carries a scar that will never fully heal.

A shared trauma, a collective unease about what happened in the darkness beneath their feet.

Josh Brennan is 23 years old now.

Though he looks both younger and older than his years, his body has recovered much of its strength, but his eyes retain that hollow, distant quality that appears in people who’ve seen too much.

He spends most of his time in his room.

The same room he left seven years ago, though it feels foreign to him now.

The posters on the walls, the baseball trophies, the guitar, they belong to a different person, a boy who no longer exists.

Sometimes Caroline finds him standing at the window, staring out at nothing in particular, and she wonders what he’s thinking.

She asks gently, and he always says the same thing.

Nothing, Mom.

I’m not thinking about anything.

But she doesn’t believe him.

How could he not be thinking about it? How could anyone experience what he experienced and simply move on? Liam Carter has made slightly more progress, at least outwardly.

He’s begun taking short walks around the neighborhood, always during daylight hours, never straying far from home.

Diane walks with him, staying close, as if afraid that if she lets him out of her sight, he’ll disappear again.

They don’t talk much during these walks.

Liam seems content with silence, and Diane has learned not to push, but sometimes when they pass the road that leads toward the hills, toward the tunnel, Liam stops.

He stands there looking in that direction, his expression unreadable.

“Do you want to talk about it?” Diane asks and Liam shakes his head.

There’s nothing to talk about, he says, and they continue walking.

The friendship between Josh and Liam, once so close, so unbreakable, has become complicated.

They’ve seen each other only a handful of times since leaving the hospital.

When they do meet, usually at the insistence of their mothers or therapists, they sit in awkward silence, avoiding eye contact.

Dr.

Morowitz explains this as a common trauma response.

They’re reminders to each other of what they went through.

She says being together forces them to confront memories they’d rather suppress.

It’s easier to heal separately, at least for now.

Did he? But some who’ve observed them together report something else, something harder to define.

attention, a weariness, as if there’s something unsaid between them, some shared knowledge that creates distance rather than connection.

During one joint therapy session, Dr.

Morowitz asked them directly, “Is there something you’re not telling us? Something that happened in the tunnel that you’re afraid to share?” Both boys went rigid.

Josh stared at the floor.

Liam’s hands clenched into fists.

And then almost simultaneously they both said, “No, there’s nothing.” But their body language told a different story.

The FBI investigation has reached a standstill.

Special Agent Derek Foster, who’s been leading the case since March, admits they’ve hit a wall.

“We’ve analyzed every piece of evidence, interviewed everyone even remotely connected to the tunnel, followed every possible lead,” he said in a recent statement.

And we still can’t explain key elements of this case.

The phone, the supplies, the photos.

Someone else was involved, but we have no idea who or why or where they are now.

The most frustrating aspect for investigators is the boys themselves.

They’re the only ones who know what really happened, Agent Foster explained.

But either they genuinely don’t remember or they’re choosing not to tell us.

And without their cooperation, we’re operating in the dark, literally and figuratively.

There are theories, of course.

There are always theories.

Online communities dedicated to the case have generated hundreds of them, ranging from plausible to absurd.

Some believe the boys were kidnapped and held in a hidden chamber within the tunnel, periodically supplied by their captor.

Others think they found an old fallout shelter or railroad maintenance facility that had stockpiled provisions.

A few suggest they weren’t in the tunnel the entire time, that they emerged at some point, lived elsewhere, and returned to the tunnel only shortly before being found, staging their own rescue for reasons unknown.

The more outlandish theories involve everything from government experiments to time distortions to supernatural intervention.

These are easily dismissed by investigators, but they persist in online forums and late night discussions, testament to humanity’s need to find meaning in the inexplicable.

Dr.

Hammond, the physician who oversaw their recovery, has her own theory, though she admits it’s just speculation.

I think they found some kind of equilibrium in there, she said.

Not comfort, certainly not happiness, but a way of existing that their minds and bodies adapted to.

And I think something happened, something traumatic, even beyond the baseline trauma of being trapped that they’ve blocked out.

Until they’re ready to confront that, we may never know the full truth.

The tunnel itself has become something of a dark pilgrimage site.

Despite the sealed entrance and no trespassing signs, people regularly visit, leaving flowers, notes, teddy bears, and other momentos at the barrier.

Some leave messages for Josh and Liam.

Others leave prayers.

A few leave questions.

What did you see in there? Who helped you? What aren’t you telling us? The local authorities have had to station cameras at the site to discourage break-in attempts.

There have been several incidents of people trying to access the tunnel, drawn by morbid curiosity or the belief that they might find some clue the professionals missed.

All have been caught and charged with trespassing.

Caroline and Diane no longer visit the tunnel.

They’ve seen enough of it, lived with it long enough.

Their focus now is entirely on their sons, helping them heal, supporting them, trying to build some kind of future from the wreckage of the past.

It’s not easy.

Both women bear their own scars from the seven years of grief, the separation from their husbands, the psychological toll of not knowing.

But they’re survivors, too, in their own way.

I have my son back, Caroline said in a rare interview in July.

That’s what matters.

I don’t care what happened in that tunnel.

I don’t care about the mystery or the unanswered questions.

I have Josh back and that’s enough.

But even as she said it, her eyes told a different story because it’s not enough.

Not really.

The questions haunt her.

The not knowing keeps her up at night.

And sometimes when she looks at her son, she sees a stranger, someone who wears Josh’s face, but carries secrets she can’t access, experiences she can’t understand.

The truth is, we may never know what really happened in the Thornton Tunnel during those seven years.

We may never understand how two teenage boys survived the impossible or who, if anyone, helped them.

We may never learn what they saw, what they endured.

What changed them so fundamentally that they can’t or won’t speak of it.

What we do know is this.

Josh Brennan and Liam Carter walked into that tunnel as carefree 16-year-olds looking for adventure.

And 7 years later, two hollow-eyed young men emerged, carrying darkness inside them that no amount of sunlight can fully dispel.

They survived.

But at what cost? And what did they leave behind in those lightless passages, pieces of themselves perhaps, or secrets too terrible to bring back to the surface? The Thornton tunnel sits silent now, sealed and watched, keeping its mysteries.

But sometimes late at night, people who live near the hills report hearing sounds faint, distant, echoing through the earth.

Voices, they say, or maybe just the wind moving through passages no one has fully explored.

And Josh and Liam, when asked if they ever dream about the tunnel, give the same answer every night.

But they never say what they dream.

They never describe what they see when they close their eyes and the darkness returns.

And perhaps that’s their right.

Perhaps some experiences are too profound, too personal, too terrible to share.

Perhaps the only way to survive the darkness is to keep it locked inside where it can’t hurt anyone else.

The case remains open.

The questions remain unanswered.

And somewhere in Grafton, West Virginia, two young men are learning to live with ghosts that only they can see.

What do you think happened in that tunnel? What secrets do you believe Josh and Liam are keeping? Could you survive 7 years in complete darkness? Or is there something more to this story than we’ve been told? Share your thoughts in the comments below.

I read every single one, and I’d love to hear your theories.

If this story moved you, if it made you think, if it left you with questions you can’t shake, please consider subscribing to the channel.

Hit that notification bell so you never miss another deep dive into the mysteries that define us, the stories that haunt us, and the questions that remain unanswered.

Thank you for being here, for listening, for caring about these two young men and their impossible journey.

Until next time, stay curious, stay compassionate, and remember, sometimes the deepest mysteries aren’t found in the darkness outside, but in the shadows we carry within.