Best friends went missing backpacking in Utah canyons.

12 years later, their voices were recorded at night.

The Red Rock Canyons of southern Utah have always held a certain kind of silence, vast, ancient, and unforgiving.

For those who venture into their depths, the beauty is breathtaking, but the isolation is absolute.

It’s a place where cell service disappears, where trails fade into slick rock, and where the desert swallows sound.

In the spring of 2013, two young men set out into that wilderness with nothing but backpacks, maps, and the kind of confidence that comes from years of friendship.

Their names were Ethan Cross and Dylan Mercer.

Both 24 years old, both graduates of the University of Arizona, and both experienced hikers who had spent countless weekends exploring the back country of the American Southwest.

Ethan was the planner, tall, lean, with dark hair, always tucked under a worn baseball cap.

He was the one who studied topographic maps late into the night, who marked way points on his GPS, who calculated water sources and mileage with the precision of an engineer, which he was.

He worked for a renewable energy startup in Flagstaff, designing solar arrays, but his real passion was the desert.

Dylan, on the other hand, was the storyteller, broad-shouldered and quick to laugh.

He had a degree in journalism and dreams of writing a book about the American West.

He carried a battered notebook everywhere, filled with sketches, quotes, and half-finished essays.

The two had met in college during a rock climbing trip, and had been inseparable ever since.

Their plan for late April 2013 was ambitious, but not unusual for them.

a six-day loop through the Robbers Roost area, a remote and rugged section of canyon country west of the Dirty Devil River.

It was a place few people visited, known for its maze-like drainages, hidden arches, and the kind of solitude that felt like stepping back in time.

They told Ethan’s girlfriend, Mia, and Dylan’s younger brother, Connor, where they were going.

They left a detailed itinerary, marked their entry point on a map, and promised to check in as soon as they got back to sell service.

On the morning of April 22nd, they drove Ethan’s dusty Subaru down a washboard dirt road, parked at the trail head, locked the doors, and walked into the canyon.

No one would see them again.

At first, no one was worried.

Ethan and Dylan were known for losing track of time in the back country, for extending trips if the weather was good, or if they stumbled onto something worth exploring.

But when a full week passed with no word, Mia called Connor and together they called the Emory County Sheriff’s Office.

A search was launched on May 2nd, 10 days after the two had entered the canyon.

Before we go further into this story, I want to take a moment to thank you for being here.

If you’re drawn to mysteries like this, stories that stay with you long after the screen goes dark, then this channel is for you.

Please consider subscribing and turning on notifications so you never miss an episode.

Your support means everything.

Now, let’s continue.

The search and rescue team found Ethan’s Subaru exactly where it was supposed to be, covered in a thin layer of dust, but otherwise undisturbed.

Inside, they found protein bar wrappers, a half empty water bottle, and a charging cable plugged into the cigarette lighter.

The trail head registry showed their signatures dated April 22nd, 9:17 a.m.

But beyond that point, the trail went cold.

The robbers’s roost area spans over 300 square miles of slick rock, sandstone cliffs, and winding canyons.

There are no marked trails, no signs, no infrastructure.

Searchers brought in helicopters, K-9 units, and volunteers from across the state.

They combed the most likely routes, checked water sources, and scanned the canyon floors from above.

They found nothing.

No footprints, no abandoned gear, no sign of a struggle or a fall.

Ethan’s family was devastated.

His mother, Linda Cross, a retired school teacher, flew in from Oregon and stayed in a motel in Hanksville, the nearest town.

She walked the streets handing out flyers, her hands shaking as she taped them to gas station windows and community boards.

Dylan’s father, Robert Mercer, a stoic man who ran a hardware store in Tucson, joined the search himself, hiking into the canyons day after day until his boots were worn through, but the desert gave them nothing.

Weeks turned into months.

The official search was scaled back, then suspended.

The case remained open, but with no evidence of foul play and no bodies, there was little law enforcement could do.

Ethan and Dylan became another pair of names on the long, grim list of people who had vanished into the Utah wilderness.

The families never stopped looking.

They hired private search teams, consulted psychics, posted on missing persons forums, and kept the story alive in local media.

Mia, who had planned to move in with Ethan that summer, eventually packed up his things and stored them in her parents’ garage, unable to throw anything away.

Connor, Dylan’s brother, carried his notebook with him everywhere, reading the entries over and over, searching for some clue, some hidden meaning in his brother’s words.

But there was nothing.

Just descriptions of sunsets, sketches of canyon walls, and a line Dylan had written on the last page.

Out here, you remember how small you are.

And somehow that feels like freedom.

Years passed.

The families aged.

The case grew cold.

Ethan and Dylan became ghosts, remembered by those who loved them, but forgotten by the world until the night of September 14th, 2025, when a group of hikers camped in the same area and heard something that should have been impossible.

To understand what happened on April 22nd, 2013, we have to reconstruct the day from the fragments left behind, the itinerary Ethan wrote, the timestamps on the photos found later on Dylan’s recovered SD card, and the terrain itself, which tells its own unforgiving story.

Ethan and Dylan entered the canyon system at 9:17 a.m., according to the trail head registry.

The temperature that morning was 58°, perfect hiking weather, with clear skies stretching endlessly overhead.

They carried 60 lb packs loaded with seven days of food, a water filtration system, sleeping bags, a tent, climbing rope, and 2 L of water each.

Ethan had his GPS unit fully charged, programmed with waypoints marking natural springs and campsites.

Dylan had his camera, a cannon rebel, and that notebook he never left behind.

The first few miles were easy, a gentle descent into a broad drainage known as Horseshoe Canyon, a place famous among canyon enthusiasts for its ancient petroglyphs and towering sandstone walls.

Photos recovered from Dylan’s camera show them smiling at the trail head, Ethan adjusting his pack straps, Dylan giving a thumbs up to the lens.

The timestamps read 9:43 a.m., 10:12 a.m., 11:05 a.m.

All routine shots of red rock formations, barrel cactus, and the endless blue sky above.

By midday, they would have reached the first fork in the canyon system, a place where three drainages converge.

According to Ethan’s itinerary, they planned to head west into Blue John Canyon, a narrow slot famous for its sculpted walls and seasonal pools.

This was remote even by Utah standards.

An area so isolated that when explorer Aaron Rston was trapped there in 2003, it took rescuers days to even locate him, and only because he’d left detailed plans.

Ethan and Dylan knew this.

They respected the desert’s dangers.

They carried maps, a compass, a satellite communicator, though that device, investigators would later note, was never activated.

The last photo on Dylan’s camera was taken at 2:47 p.m.

It shows Ethan standing at the edge of a narrow chasm.

His back to the camera, one hand shading his eyes as he looks down into the shadows.

The slot canyon behind him glows with reflected light.

The sandstone walls rippling like frozen water.

There’s no indication of trouble, no sign of distress, just two friends on an adventure doing what they loved.

But somewhere between that photo and the moment the sun set over the canyon rim, something went catastrophically wrong.

Search and rescue teams would later theorize multiple possibilities.

The most likely, they said, was a flash flood.

The weather records for April 22nd showed clear skies in the immediate area, but 20 m to the north near the town of Green River, a sudden thunderstorm had dumped half an inch of rain in under an hour.

In Canyon Country, that’s all it takes.

Water doesn’t soak into the slick rock.

It runs fast.

A storm you can’t even see can send a wall of water surging through a slot canyon miles away, carrying boulders, logs, and anything caught in its path.

Hikers caught in flash floods are sometimes never found.

Their bodies wedged deep in underwater crevices or buried under tons of sediment.

But if that’s what happened, why was there no evidence? Searchers checked every drainage for debris, scoured the canyon floors for disturbed sediment, and consulted hydraologists who mapped likely flood paths.

Nothing.

No fresh scour marks, no driftwood jams, no sign that water had moved through the area with unusual violence.

The second theory was a climbing accident.

Ethan and Dylan carried rope and both were experienced climbers.

Perhaps they attempted a repel into a deeper section of the canyon and something went wrong.

An anchor failure.

A rockfall, a miscommunication.

But again, searchers found no rope, no webbing, no climbing gear left behind.

If they’d fallen, their bodies should have been visible from the air.

The helicopter crews flew low and slow, scanning every cliff base, every talis slope, every shadowed al cove.

They saw nothing.

The third theory, whispered but never officially stated, was foul play.

The robber’s roost area earned its name in the late 1800s when outlaws like Butch Cassidy used its labyrinthine canyons to hide from lawmen.

Even today, it’s a place where people go to disappear.

Survivalists, fugitives, those running from something.

Could Ethan and Dylan have stumbled onto someone who didn’t want to be found? The Emery County Sheriff’s Office quietly investigated this angle, checking for reports of suspicious activity, interviewing known transients and reviewing criminal records of individuals with ties to the area.

They found nothing credible.

No witnesses, no confessions, no evidence of violence.

Linda Cross, Ethan’s mother, developed her own theory, one she shared in a tearful interview with a Salt Lake City news station 6 months after the disappearance.

She believed her son and Dylan had found something, a hidden archaeological site maybe, or a cave with Native American artifacts, and had ventured too deep, becoming disoriented and lost.

The canyon systems in that area are notoriously confusing, she said, with passages that twist back on themselves, dead ends that look like throughways, and vertical drops hidden by shadows.

My son was careful, she said, her voice breaking.

But even careful people make mistakes.

And out there, one mistake is all it takes.

Dylan’s father, Robert, had a different perspective.

A pragmatic man who’d spent his life fixing broken things.

He believed the answer was simpler.

Dehydration and exposure.

They ran out of water, he told a reporter from the Tucson Daily Star.

Maybe their filter broke.

Maybe they misjudged the distance to the next spring.

They got disoriented, made bad decisions, and collapsed somewhere off the main routs.

The desert took them.

He said it without emotion.

But those who knew him said he never slept through the night again.

Mia, Ethan’s girlfriend, couldn’t accept any of it.

She kept his phone bill active for 3 years, hoping it would ping a tower somewhere somehow.

She monitored online forums where hikers posted trip reports from the robbers Roost area, searching for mentions of anything unusual.

a strange can, a discarded backpack, bones.

She found nothing but sympathy and empty speculation.

By 2015, the official search had long been suspended.

The families held a memorial service without bodies, a painful ritual that felt like giving up.

Ethan’s belongings were divided among his siblings.

Dylan’s notebook was placed in a safety deposit box, too precious to read, too painful to destroy.

The case file at the Emory County Sheriff’s Office gathered dust stamped with a single word, unresolved.

And then 12 years later, on a cool September night in 2025, three hikers camped near the same fork in the canyon where Ethan and Dylan were last seen.

They set up their tents just after sunset, cooked dinner on a portable stove, and settled in for the night.

At approximately 11:42 p.m., one of them, a wildlife biologist named Dr.

Sarah Ortiz, woke to the sound of voices echoing through the canyon.

Male voices, distant but distinct, and they were calling for help.

The first official search operation launched on May 2nd, 2013, 10 days after Ethan Cross and Dylan Mercer walked into the canyon.

By that time, temperatures in the robbers’s roost area had climbed into the high 80s during the day, and any hope of finding the men alive was fading fast.

The human body can survive 3 days without water under ideal conditions.

In the Utah desert, that window is even shorter.

Sheriff Tom Barkley of Emery County coordinated the effort from a command post set up in the parking lot of the Hollow Mountain Gas Station in Hanksville, a tiny town of about 200 people that serves as the gateway to the surrounding wilderness.

Barkley was a third generation Utah native, a man who’d spent his entire life in Canyon Country and had worked dozens of search and rescue operations.

He knew the terrain, knew its dangers, and knew the grim statistics.

Of the people who go missing in the Utah back country, fewer than half are found alive.

The initial search team consisted of 12 volunteers from the San Raphael Search and Rescue, a nonprofit organization staffed by experienced desert hikers, cavers, and technical climbers.

They divided into three groups, each assigned a different drainage based on Ethan’s itinerary.

The plan was methodical.

Start at the trail head.

Follow the most likely route.

Check every side canyon, every overhang, every water source.

They carried radios, GPS units, satellite phones, and high-powered binoculars.

Two helicopters from the Utah Department of Public Safety joined the effort, equipped with infrared cameras capable of detecting body heat from a thousand ft up.

Linda Cross arrived in Hanksville on May 3rd, her eyes red and swollen, her hands clutching a stack of flyers she’d printed at a Kinko’s in Salt Lake City.

The flyers showed photos of Ethan and Dylan side by side, smiling, healthy, alive.

Missing two hikers in robbers Roost area.

Last seen April 27th, 2013.

Please call with any information.

She taped them to every available surface.

the gas station window, the post office bulletin board, the door of the Whispering Sands motel where she’d rented a room.

People in town were kind but cautious.

They’d seen this before.

The desert took people, and it rarely gave them back.

Dylan’s father, Robert Mercer, arrived the next day with Connor, Dylan’s 21-year-old brother.

Robert was a man of few words, but his face betrayed his anguish.

He met with Sheriff Barkley in the parking lot, spreading Ethan’s hand-drawn map across the hood of a truck.

They’re smart kids, Robert said, his voice tight.

They wouldn’t take risks.

If something happened, it happened fast.

Barkley nodded.

We’re doing everything we can, Mr.

Mercer.

But I need you to understand.

This is a big area.

300 square miles of some of the roughest terrain in the state.

We’ll find them, but it’s going to take time.

By May 5th, the search had expanded to include 30 volunteers and a third helicopter.

Teams hiked from dawn until dusk, their boots crunching over slick rock, their voices calling out into the silence.

Ethan, Dylan, can you hear us? The canyon walls threw their voices back at them, mocking and empty.

They checked every natural spring marked on Ethan’s itinerary.

Larry Canyon Spring, Twin Corral Spring, Horse Thief Spring, and found no sign that anyone had visited recently.

No footprints in the mud, no crushed vegetation, no discarded water bottles.

On May 7th, a volunteer named Jake Holloway, a 38-year-old paramedic from Moab, found something.

It was in a narrow slot canyon about 4 mi west of the trail head, wedged between two boulders at the base of a 15- ft drop.

A blue stuff sack.

The kind used to organize gear inside a backpack.

Jake radioed immediately, his heart pounding.

I’ve got something.

Blue bag.

Looks like it could be theirs.

Within an hour, Sheriff Barkley and a forensic technician had hiked to the location.

They photographed the stuff sack from multiple angles before carefully extracting it from the rocks.

Inside, they found a water filter, a first aid kit, and a bundle of energy bars.

The items were dry, undamaged, and clearly hadn’t been there long.

The filter was an MSR Mini Works, a popular model.

Ethan’s gear list, provided by Mia, confirmed he’d brought that exact filter.

The discovery electrified the search.

If this was their gear, it meant they’d made it at least this far.

But why would they abandon a water filter? And if they dropped it accidentally, why not come back for it? The stuff sack had been found at the base of a drop.

Had they repelled down and lost it in the process? Searchers scoured the area looking for rope anchors, webbing, any sign of a descent.

They found nothing.

Linda Cross was brought to the command post to look at the items.

She held the blue stuff sack in her hands, turning it over slowly.

This could be Ethan’s, she said quietly.

He had one just like this, but I can’t be sure.

Her voice cracked.

Please keep looking.

The next day, May 8th, one of the helicopters made a gruesome discovery.

Human remains in a shallow al cove 6 mi south of the trail head in a completely different drainage than the one Ethan and Dylan were expected to take.

The remains were badly decomposed, scattered by scavengers.

Sheriff Barklay’s heart sank.

He ordered the helicopter to land, and a recovery team hiked in with body bags and evidence kits.

But when the medical examiner later analyzed the remains, the conclusion was crushing for a different reason.

The bones belonged to a male in his 50s or 60s and had been there for at least a year, possibly longer.

DNA tests eventually identified him as Gregory Foster, a drifter from Nevada who’d been reported missing in 2011.

The discovery had nothing to do with Ethan and Dylan.

It was just another body in the desert, another person who’d walked into the wilderness and never come out.

By May 12th, the search had been ongoing for 10 days.

Volunteers were exhausted, resources were stretched, and the chances of finding Ethan and Dylan alive were now statistically zero.

Sheriff Barkley made the difficult decision to scale back operations.

“We’re not giving up,” he told the families in a grim meeting at the command post.

“But we have to be realistic.

We’ve covered every major drainage, checked every water source, and flown over a 100 square miles of terrain.

If they’re out there, they’re in a place we haven’t thought to look yet.

Robert Mercer stood abruptly, his chair scraping against the pavement.

So that’s it.

You’re just going to leave them out there? Barkley’s face was pained.

Mr.

Mercer, I understand your frustration, but we’ve got volunteers who’ve been hiking 12 hours a day in brutal heat.

We’ve spent tens of thousands of dollars in helicopter fuel alone.

The reality is this area is too big, too complex.

We’ll continue periodic sweeps and if we get new information, new information? Robert’s voice rose.

What new information? They’re out there right now and you’re giving up.

Connor put a hand on his father’s arm.

Dad, please.

Robert pulled away, his jaw clenched, and walked out into the parking lot.

Linda Cross sat in her chair, silent tears streaming down her face.

Mia, sitting beside her, reached over and took her hand.

The official search was suspended on May 15th, 2013.

In total, the operation had involved more than 50 volunteers, three helicopters, two K-9 units, and had covered approximately 80 square miles of terrain.

The only piece of evidence recovered was the blue stuff sack with the water filter, and even that couldn’t be definitively linked to Ethan and Dylan.

The case was reclassified as a cold missing person’s case, and the families were left with nothing but questions.

In the weeks that followed, private search efforts continued.

Robert and Connor returned to the canyons every weekend for months, hiking until their legs gave out.

Linda hired a private investigator, a former FBI agent named Marcus Lavine, who spent two weeks in the area interviewing locals, reviewing topographic maps, and consulting with geologists.

Lavine’s final report was six pages long and concluded with a single sentence.

Without additional evidence or eyewitness testimony, the probability of locating the missing individuals is less than 5%.

Mia organized a fundraiser to pay for additional helicopter flights.

They raised $12,000, enough for three more aerial surveys.

Pilots flew in grid patterns, circling slowly over the canyon systems, scanning the ground below.

They saw nothing but rock, sand, and shadow.

By the fall of 2013, the searches had stopped.

The families returned to their lives, carrying grief that had no resolution, no body to bury, no closure.

Ethan’s room in Linda’s house remained untouched.

His climbing gear still hanging in the garage.

Dylan’s notebook sat in Connor’s apartment wrapped in plastic, a relic of a life cut short.

The desert had swallowed them whole, and for 12 years, it kept its secret.

The first year after the disappearance was the hardest.

Linda Cross couldn’t bring herself to remove Ethan’s name from her phone contacts.

She’d scroll through her messages, sometimes reading the last text he’d sent her the night before he left.

Love you, Mom.

See you in a week.

Don’t worry.

Three crying, laughing emojis.

That was so Ethan trying to make her laugh even as he headed into the wilderness.

She’d stare at those words until her vision blurred, wondering if she’d somehow missed a hidden meaning, a clue, a cry for help disguised as reassurance.

Robert Mercer went the opposite direction.

He boxed up everything that reminded him of Dylan.

Photos, the journalism degree hanging on the wall, even the hardware store employee schedule where Dylan’s name was still penciled in for summer shifts he’d never work.

Robert stored it all in the attic and never spoke his son’s name aloud again.

His wife, Patricia, tried to get him to talk to a therapist to join a grief support group, but he refused.

“Talking won’t bring him back,” he said flatly.

“The hardware store became his refuge.

He’d worked 12-hour days fixing faucets and cutting keys, exhausting himself so completely that he’d fall asleep the moment his head hit the pillow.

It was the only way he could stop the questions from circling in his mind.

Connor, Dylan’s younger brother, took a leave of absence from college and never went back.

He’d been studying architecture at Arizona State, but after his brother vanished, the idea of designing buildings, of creating permanent things in a world where people could just disappear felt absurd.

He moved to Moab, Utah, a small desert town about 90 mi from where Dylan was last seen, and got a job as a river guide on the Colorado River.

He told people it was to be closer to the search area, but the truth was more complicated.

Out on the river, surrounded by canyon walls, he felt connected to his brother somehow, as if Dylan’s absence was less absolute here, where the landscape itself seemed to exist outside of time.

Mia tried to move on.

She really did.

She dated other people, threw herself into her work as a veterinary technician, even moved to Denver for a fresh start.

But every time her phone rang late at night, her heart would leap.

Irrational hope that maybe somehow it was Ethan, that he’d been injured, had amnesia, had been wandering the desert for months, and finally found his way to civilization.

It never was.

In 2016, 3 years after the disappearance, she finally agreed to see a therapist who specialized in ambiguous loss.

The unique trauma of losing someone without confirmation of death.

“You’re stuck,” the therapist told her gently.

“Part of you is still waiting for him to walk through the door.” Mia nodded, tears streaming down her face.

“I know, but what if he does?” The therapist didn’t have an answer for that.

By 2015, the story had faded from the news.

Missing persons cases, unless they involve children or suspicious circumstances, rarely hold public attention for long.

The Emory County Sheriff’s Office kept the case file open.

But with no new leads, there was nothing to investigate.

Sheriff Barkley retired in 2017 and the case was transferred to a younger detective named Amanda Reyes who reviewed the file, made a few phone calls to the families to let them know she was now the point of contact and then filed it away.

There were more pressing cases.

Domestic violence, drug trafficking, the occasional homicide.

Two missing hikers from 2013 with no evidence of foul play simply couldn’t compete for resources.

The families tried to keep the story alive.

Linda created a Facebook page called Finding Ethan Cross and Dylan Mercer, where she posted updates, shared memories, and pleaded for anyone with information to come forward.

At first, the page attracted thousands of followers, true crime enthusiasts, amateur sleuths, people who’d had their own experiences with missing loved ones.

But as the years dragged on with no updates, no breakthroughs, the engagement dwindled.

By 2020, Linda’s posts, birthday messages to Ethan, anniversary remembrances of the day he disappeared, received only a handful of likes, and the occasional generic comment, still praying for answers.

In 2018, on the fifth anniversary of the disappearance, the families organized a memorial hike into the robbers Roost area.

About 20 people showed up, family members, a few old friends from college, some volunteers from the original search and rescue team.

They hiked to the trail head where Ethan and Dylan had signed the registry, and Linda read a poem she’d written.

Connor played Wish You Were Here by Pink Floyd on a battery powered speaker, Dylan’s favorite song.

They scattered wildflower seeds at the spot where the blue stuff sack had been found, hoping something beautiful might grow there.

Robert didn’t attend.

He told Patricia he had to work, but the truth was he couldn’t bear it.

The hike, the poem, the music, it all felt like giving up, like admitting they were really gone.

Connor kept searching, though his methods grew increasingly desperate.

He became obsessed with online forums dedicated to missing person’s cases, spending hours each night reading theories, studying satellite imagery, corresponding with self-proclaimed experts.

One user claiming to be a retired search and rescue professional suggested that Ethan and Dylan might have fallen into an unmapped cave system.

“That whole area is riddled with voids,” the user wrote.

“They could be 20 ft below where searchers walked, and no one would ever know.” Connor drove back to the canyons alone, armed with a metal detector and a map marked with cave entrances reported by Spelunkers over the years.

He spent two weeks camping in his truck, hiking into side canyons, checking every dark opening he could find.

He found old cowboy camps, pictographs, even a minehaft from the 1800s, but no sign of his brother.

On his last day, standing on a ridge overlooking the maze of red rock below, he screamed Dylan’s name until his voice gave out.

The canyon swallowed the sound without echo.

That was when Connor finally accepted that Dylan wasn’t coming back.

Not alive.

Anyway, Mia accepted it, too.

Eventually, in 2019, she started dating a man named Trevor, a high school teacher who was patient, kind, and understood that part of her would always belong to someone else.

They got engaged in 2021.

On her wedding day, Mia wore a silver bracelet engraved with Ethan’s initials.

“He would want you to be happy,” her maid of honor told her.

Mia smiled, but she wasn’t sure that was true.

She wasn’t sure Ethan would want anything anymore.

He existed now only in memory.

Frozen at 24, forever young, forever lost.

Linda stopped updating the Facebook page in 2022.

Not because she’d given up hope, but because the hope had transformed into something quieter, heavier, a certainty that she would die without knowing what happened to her son.

She was 71 years old.

Her health was declining.

The not knowing had aged her in ways that grief alone couldn’t explain.

Robert sold the hardware store in 2023 and moved with Patricia to a retirement community in Phoenix.

He never returned to Utah.

I’ve said my goodbyes, he told Connor over the phone.

Connor didn’t argue.

Everyone grieved differently.

By 2025, 12 years had passed.

Ethan Cross and Dylan Mercer had become the kind of story that only surfaced occasionally.

A mention on a true crime podcast, a post in a Reddit forum dedicated to unsolved mysteries, a cautionary tale about the dangers of the Utah back country.

Most people who’d known them had moved on with their lives.

The desert, indifferent and eternal, kept its secrets.

And then on the night of September 14th, 2025, everything changed.

Doctor Sarah Ortiz, a wildlife biologist from New Mexico, was camped in the Robbers Roost area with two colleagues conducting field research on desert big horn sheep.

They’d chosen a site near the same fork in the canyon where Ethan and Dylan were last known to have been, not because they knew about the disappearance, but because the terrain provided good vantage points for observing wildlife.

They set up camp just before sunset, ate freeze-dried meals heated over a portable stove, and settled into their tents around 9:30 p.m.

Sarah fell asleep quickly, exhausted from a long day of hiking.

But at 11:42 p.m., she woke suddenly, her heart pounding.

There were voices outside, male voices, distant, but clear enough to make out words.

“Help us,” one voice called, echoing off the canyon walls.

Please, someone.

Sarah sat up, fumbling for her headlamp.

She unzipped her tent and stepped out into the cold desert night.

The moon was a thin crescent, offering little light.

She aimed her headlamp into the darkness, sweeping the beam across the canyon.

“Hello,” she called.

“Where are you?” The voices continued, overlapping now, desperate.

“We’re lost.

We need help.

Please.” Sarah’s colleagues, Martin and Jessica, emerged from their tents, their faces pale.

“You hear that?” Martin whispered.

Jessica nodded, her hand gripping a can of bear spray, even though there were no bears in this part of Utah.

“Where is it coming from?” The three of them stood in the darkness, listening.

The voices seemed to move, echoing from different directions.

first to the west, then the south, then impossibly close, as if someone were standing just beyond the circle of light cast by their headlamps, but there was no one there.

And then Sarah realized something that made her blood run cold.

She pulled out her phone and opened a voice recording app.

Her hands were shaking, but she managed to press record.

The voices continued for another 3 minutes before fading into silence.

When they stopped, the desert was utterly quiet.

No wind, no crickets, nothing.

The three researchers didn’t sleep the rest of the night.

At dawn on September 15th, 2025, Dr.

Sarah Ortiz and her colleagues packed up their camp with trembling hands and drove straight to the Emery County Sheriff’s Office in Castle Dale.

Sarah carried her phone like it contained a live bomb.

The recording she’d made in the darkness, 4 minutes and 17 seconds of disembodied voices calling for help, felt both impossible and undeniable.

She’d listened to it three times on the drive, each time feeling the hair rise on the back of her neck.

The deputy on duty, a young man named Kyle Patterson, listened politely but skeptically as Sarah explained what had happened.

He was in his late 20s, too young to remember the original search for Ethan Cross and Dylan Mercer.

When Sarah played the recording, though, his expression changed.

The voices were clear, desperate, unmistakably human.

“Help us, please.

We’re lost.

Someone help us.

This could be a prank,” Patterson said carefully.

“People camp out there.

Maybe some kids at midnight,” Sarah interrupted.

in the middle of nowhere and we searched with our lights.

There was no one there.

Patterson made a call to detective Amanda Reyes who arrived at the station within the hour.

Reyes was 42, sharpeyed with 15 years of experience in law enforcement.

She’d inherited the Cross Mercer case when Sheriff Barkley retired, and while it wasn’t her highest priority, she’d reviewed the file enough times to know the details by heart.

When she heard the recording, she felt something shift in her chest.

A mixture of disbelief and professional instinct.

“Can you send me the exact GPS coordinates of where you were camped?” Reyes asked, pulling out a laptop.

Sarah forwarded the location.

Reyes opened the case file and cross referenced the coordinates with the maps from the 2013 search.

Her screen showed a detailed topographic overlay with colored markers indicating areas that had been searched, water sources, and the location where the blue stuff sack had been found.

Sarah’s campsite was less than half a mile from that spot.

Reyes looked up, her face grim.

I need to make some calls.

Within 3 days, a new search operation was organized.

This time, the focus was narrower, but more intensive.

a thorough sweep of the immediate area around where the voices had been heard using technology that hadn’t been available in 2013.

Ground penetrating radar, thermal imaging drones, and acoustic monitoring equipment were brought in along with a specialized team from the National Park Service experienced in recovering remains from remote locations.

Linda Cross received the call on September 18th.

Detective Reyes explained the situation carefully, not wanting to give false hope, but knowing the family deserved to know.

Linda’s first reaction was disbelief, then a desperate, painful surge of hope.

You think they’re alive after 12 years? Mrs.

Cross, Reyes said gently.

I don’t want to speculate, but we’re taking this seriously.

Something unusual happened out there, and we need to investigate.

Connor was contacted next.

He was guiding a rafting trip when his phone buzzed with Reyes’s message.

He pulled over at the next river access point and called her back immediately.

When she explained about the voices, he felt something he hadn’t felt in years.

Adrenaline, purpose, the sense that maybe finally they’d find answers.

He canled the rest of his trips and drove to Utah that night.

The new search began on September 21st.

The team included 12 specialists, two drones, three K-9 units trained in cadaavver detection, and Detective Reyes herself.

Sarah Ortiz volunteered to guide them to the exact spot where she’d heard the voices.

Standing in daylight, the location seemed ordinary, just another bend in the canyon, sandstone walls rising on three sides, scattered juniper trees, and silence.

“We were camped right here,” Sarah said, pointing to the flattened patches of sand where their tents had been.

The voices seemed to come from every direction.

“Echo effects,” I thought at first.

“But but what?” Reyes asked.

Sarah hesitated.

They moved like whoever was calling was walking, but we searched.

There was no one there.

The K9 units were deployed first.

The dogs worked methodically, noses to the ground, handlers watching for any change in behavior, a pause, a whine, a sudden focus.

For 3 hours, the dogs found nothing.

Then just after noon, a Belgian Malininoa named Ranger stopped abruptly near the base of a cliff about 200 yards south of Sarah’s campsite.

The dog sat.

A trained signal that he’d detected something.

His handler, a woman named Carla Voss, called Reyes over immediately.

He’s got something, Carla said.

Right here.

The area looked unremarkable.

A pile of rocks at the base of a vertical sandstone wall.

the kind of talis slope that exists in a thousand places throughout the canyon system.

But when the team began carefully moving stones, they found something that made Ryes’s breath catch.

Fabric, faded, sunbleleached, but unmistakably synthetic.

A piece of blue nylon about 6 in square, wedged between two boulders.

They worked slowly, documenting every step with photographs and notes.

As they removed more rocks, the fabric became more extensive.

a backpack compressed and torn but still intact.

Inside they found a water bottle, a headlamp with dead batteries, a crumpled trail map, and most significantly a driver’s license.

The photo showed a young man with dark hair and a slight smile.

The name read Ethan Michael Cross.

Reyes made the call to Linda Cross from the site.

Mrs.

Cross, we found something.

Ethan’s backpack.

I’m so sorry, but we believe there are human remains nearby.

We’re working to recover everything now.

Linda’s scream could be heard through the phone from 10 ft away.

Over the next 2 days, forensic teams carefully excavated the site.

What they found told a grim but coherent story.

Beneath the rockfall were the skeletal remains of two individuals positioned close together, as if they’d been huddled for warmth or comfort.

The bones showed no signs of trauma, no broken skulls, no fractured ribs, nothing to indicate violence or a fall.

Dental records later confirmed what everyone already knew.

The remains belonged to Ethan Cross and Dylan Mercer.

But it was what else they found that transformed the case from a tragic hiking accident into something far more haunting.

Partially buried near Dylan’s remains was his camera, miraculously protected by its padded case.

The SD card inside was damaged but recoverable.

A forensic lab in Salt Lake City worked for 3 days to extract the data and what they found made Detective Reyes call Sarah Ortiz immediately.

Dr.

Ortiz, Reyes said, her voice tight.

I need to ask you something.

When you heard those voices, did either of them sound young, like someone in their early 20s? Sarah thought carefully.

Yes, both of them.

Why? Reyes took a breath.

We recovered a camera from the site.

The last photos on it show the men alive on April 22nd, 2013, the day they disappeared, but there’s also a video file dated April 25th, 3 days later.

They were still alive then, and they were trying to signal for help.

The video, when played, was devastating.

The footage was shaky, poorly lit.

Filmed at dusk or dawn.

It showed Dylan’s face gaunt and sunburned.

His lips cracked.

His voice was horsearo.

If anyone finds this, we’re trapped.

We came down into this canyon and there was a rock fall behind us.

We can’t climb out.

We’ve been screaming for help for 3 days.

No one can hear us.

The walls are too high.

We’re out of water.

Ethan is The camera panned to show Ethan lying against a rock, barely conscious.

Please, if you find this, tell our families we tried.

The video ended.

Forensic geologists later determined what had happened.

Ethan and Dylan had descended into a narrow side canyon.

A dead-end drainage with vertical walls.

While they were deep inside, a seismic tremor, barely noticeable on the surface, but enough to dislodge unstable rock, had caused a collapse at the canyon entrance, sealing them in.

They’d survived for at least 3 days, possibly longer, before succumbing to dehydration and exposure.

The rockfall had been invisible from above, explaining why helicopters had missed them.

The canyon was so narrow that searchers on foot would have walked right past without noticing the entrance had been blocked, but none of that explained the voices Sarah had heard in 2025.

Detective Reyes had the recording analyzed by an audio forensics expert at the University of Utah.

The expert, Dr.

Raone Delgado spent a week studying the waveforms, filtering out background noise, and comparing the voices to samples of Ethan and Dylan speaking, videos from college, recorded interviews with family members.

His report concluded with a statement that Reyes read three times before believing the voices on the recording are consistent with the vocal patterns, pitch, and tambber of Ethan Cross and Dylan Mercer.

However, due to the degraded audio quality and echo effects, definitive identification is not possible.

The source of the voices remains unexplained.

Sarah Ortiz was shown the analysis.

She sat in silence for a long time before speaking.

So, you’re saying those were their voices, but they’ve been dead for 12 years.

Reyes didn’t answer immediately.

Finally, she said the science can’t explain it.

The recording is real.

The voices are real, but where they came from, she trailed off.

Connor, when told about the discovery, demanded to hear the recording himself.

Reyes warned him it would be difficult, but he insisted.

When the voices played, “Help us, please.

We’re lost.

Someone help us.” He closed his eyes, tears streaming down his face.

“That’s Dylan,” he whispered.

“That’s my brother.” Linda Cross never listened to the recording.

She said she couldn’t bear it.

Knowing that her son had died calling for help was already unbearable.

Hearing his voice impossibly echoing through the canyon 12 years after his death would destroy what little peace she’d managed to find.

The remains were returned to the families in October 2025.

Ethan was buried in Oregon, Dylan in Arizona.

Both funerals were attended by hundreds, friends, family, volunteers from the original search, and strangers who’d followed the case online.

The services provided closure, but they didn’t provide answers because the question remained unspoken but inescapable.

How had Sarah Ortiz heard their voices 12 years after they died, calling for help from a place where their bodies lay silent and still? In the months following the recovery of Ethan Cross and Dylan Mercer’s remains, the case attracted unprecedented attention.

What had been a tragic but straightforward missing person’s case transformed into something that defied easy explanation.

The recording of the voices, authenticated, analyzed, and verified as genuine by multiple experts, became the subject of intense scrutiny from acoustic specialists, geologists, psychologists, and even paranormal researchers.

Though Detective Reyes refused to entertain the latter, the Emory County Sheriff’s Office issued an official statement on November 3rd, 2025.

It read in part, “The remains of Ethan Cross and Dylan Mercer have been positively identified.” “Cause of death is determined to be dehydration and exposure following accidental enttrapment in a canyon system.

The case is now closed.” Regarding the audio recording made by Dr.

Sarah Ortiz on September 14th, 2025.

We acknowledge its existence, but cannot provide a definitive explanation for its origin.

We encourage the public to respect the privacy of the families during this difficult time.

But the public wasn’t satisfied with non-answers, and neither were the experts.

Dr.

Ramon Delgado, the audio forensic specialist who’d analyzed the recording, published a paper in the Journal of Forensic Acoustics titled Anomalous Voice Phenomena in Canyon Environments, a case study.

In it, he carefully avoided sensationalism, focusing instead on the acoustic properties of slot canyons.

His conclusion was measured, but unsettling.

Canyon systems can act as natural acoustic chambers, potentially preserving and reflecting sound waves in unusual ways.

However, the transmission of recognizable human speech across a 12-year temporal gap exceeds any documented acoustic phenomenon in scientific literature.

In other words, he didn’t know.

A team of geologists from the University of New Mexico visited the site in December 2025, conducting ground penetrating radar surveys and seismic studies.

Their goal was to determine whether there might be underground cavities or unusual rock formations that could explain acoustic anomalies.

What they found was fascinating but inconclusive.

The canyon system did contain several unmapped voids, small caves, and fissures in the sandstone that could theoretically amplify or redirect sound, but nothing they discovered could account for voices being heard 12 years after the speakers had died.

Dr.

Margaret Shu, a psychologist specializing in auditory hallucinations and trauma, offered a different perspective in an interview with National Public Radio.

Grief and suggestion can create powerful perceptual experiences, she explained.

Dr.

Ortiz knew she was camping in a remote, isolated location.

The human brain, especially in darkness, is primed to find patterns, to hear voices in wind, to see faces in shadows.

It’s entirely possible that what she heard was a combination of natural sounds, wind through rock formations, animal calls, even the sounds of her own breathing.

that her brain interpreted as human voices.

But this theory had a problem, the recording.

It wasn’t just Sarah who’d heard the voices.

The audio file existed.

Independent analysts had confirmed that the sounds on the recording were consistent with human speech, not wind or wildlife, and both Martin and Jessica, Sarah’s colleagues, had heard the same thing.

Mass hallucination seemed unlikely.

Sarah herself struggled with the experience.

In an interview with a documentary crew in January 2026, she spoke carefully, aware of how easily her words could be sensationalized.

“I’m a scientist,” she said.

“I don’t believe in ghosts or the paranormal, but I also can’t deny what I heard and what I recorded.

Those were human voices calling for help.

Whether they were somehow echoes of what happened 12 years ago or something else entirely, I don’t know.

I may never know.

The families had their own ways of processing the discovery.

Linda Cross, now 73 and in declining health, found a bittersweet peace in finally knowing what had happened to her son.

I spent 12 years imagining the worst, she told a journalist from the Portland Tribune.

And the truth was as bad as I feared.

But at least now I know.

I buried my son.

I said goodbye.

That’s more than many families get.

When asked about the voices, her expression darkened.

I don’t want to talk about that.

I don’t want to think about it.

My son is at rest now.

That’s what matters.

Connor Mercer had a different reaction.

He became obsessed with understanding the phenomenon.

He spent hours online reading about acoustic anomalies, studying cases of unexplained sounds in remote locations, corresponding with researchers.

He drove back to the canyon in February 2026 and camped at the exact spot where Sarah had heard the voices.

He brought recording equipment, hoping to capture something himself.

He stayed three nights listening in the darkness, but heard only silence.

“I wanted to hear him,” Connor admitted to a friend later.

“I wanted Dylan to speak to me one more time, but the canyon was empty.” “Robert Mercer, true to form, refused to engage with the mystery at all.” “My son is dead,” he said flatly when a reporter called seeking comment.

“He’s been dead for 12 years.

Anything else is just noise.

He hung up and never answered questions about the case again.

Me cross Fletcher.

She’d taken Ethan’s last name when she remarried.

Found the whole situation deeply disturbing.

For 12 years, I tried to move on, she said in a private conversation with a grief counselor.

I built a new life.

I married someone else.

I was finally at peace.

And then this happens.

And it’s like losing him all over again.

like he’s been calling for help this whole time and no one could hear him.

She requested that Detective Reyes never contact her again unless absolutely necessary.

I can’t keep living in the past, she said.

I have to let him go.

The case also attracted attention from less credible sources.

Paranormal investigation shows requested permission to film at the site, requests that were uniformly denied by the Bureau of Land Management, which manages the robber’s roost area.

Conspiracy theorists spun elaborate narratives about government cover-ups, time anomalies, and dimensional rifts.

YouTubers made sensationalized videos with titles like ghost voices in Utah Canyon, proof of the afterlife.

Detective Reyes found these exploitative and infuriating, but there was little she could do to stop them.

One theory that gained traction among serious researchers was the acoustic fossil hypothesis.

Dr.

James Keller, a physicist at Caltech, proposed that under extremely rare conditions, specific rock compositions, temperature variations, and atmospheric pressure, sound waves could theoretically be trapped in crystalline structures within canyon walls, then released years later when conditions aligned.

Think of it like a natural recording, he explained in a lecture.

The rock absorbs the vibrations, holds them, and then releases them when triggered by perhaps seismic activity, temperature changes, or even the presence of new sound waves from campers.

It was an elegant theory, and it received significant media attention.

But when other physicists reviewed Keller’s math, they found problems.

The energy required to preserve sound waves for 12 years would be enormous.

And even if the sound was somehow stored, it would degrade beyond recognition.

Human speech with its complex patterns and frequencies couldn’t survive intact.

It’s a beautiful idea, Dr.

Delgado said in response to Keller’s theory.

But the evidence doesn’t support it.

Not yet.

Anyway, another explanation came from Dr.

Emily Jang, a cognitive neuroscientist at Stanford.

She proposed that Sarah Ortiz had experienced a rare form of place memory phenomenon, a psychological effect where locations associated with intense trauma can trigger perceptual experiences in sensitive individuals.

Dr.

Ortiz was camping in a place where two young men died desperately calling for help.

Jang explained.

She may have unconsciously picked up on subtle environmental cues, patterns in the rock, the quality of the silence, even pherommones or chemical traces still present in the soil that triggered a reconstructive memory experience.

Her brain created an auditory hallucination based on the emotional resonance of the location.

But again, this didn’t explain the recording or why Martin and Jessica heard the same thing.

By spring 2026, the media attention had largely faded.

The remains had been buried, the case officially closed, and the families left to grieve in private.

The canyon returned to its timeless silence, indifferent to the questions it had raised.

“Sarah Ortiz continued her wildlife research, but never returned to the robber’s roost area.

“I got my data,” she said simply.

“There’s no reason to go back.” In private, she admitted to colleagues that the experience had shaken her understanding of reality.

I’m a scientist, she repeated like a mantra.

I believe in what can be measured and tested, but I also trust my own senses.

And what I heard that night, I heard it.

I can’t explain it, and that terrifies me.

Connor Mercer eventually found his own form of peace.

He started a foundation called Lost Voices, dedicated to supporting families of missing hikers and improving search and rescue resources in remote areas.

Dylan would have wanted something good to come from this, he said at the foundation’s launch.

He always believed in making things better, even when the world felt broken.

Detective Amanda Reyes kept the case file on her desk for months after it was officially closed.

She’d open it sometimes, late at night when the office was empty, and listen to the recording.

one more time.

The voices, desperate, young, calling for help across an impossible distance.

She never found an explanation she could accept.

Eventually, she filed it away with dozens of other cases that defied resolution.

The ones that reminded her that the world contained mysteries larger than any badge or procedure could solve.

And in the red rock canyons of southern Utah, where the wind still carves sandstone and the silence stretches for miles, the mystery remains.

Two young men died there in 2013, alone and afraid.

Their voices lost to the desert until one night, 12 years later, when somehow, impossibly, those voices found their way back into the world.

The canyon keeps its secrets.

But occasionally, it seems it also gives them back.

As I write this, nearly 3 years have passed since Ethan Cross and Dylan Mercer’s remains were discovered in that narrow canyon in southern Utah.

The cases closed, the official reports filed, the evidence cataloged and stored.

But for those who lived through it, the families, the searchers, the researchers who tried to make sense of the impossible, the questions remain as vivid as the red rock walls where two friends took their last breaths.

What really happened on September 14th, 2025? Did Sarah Ortiz and her colleagues truly hear the voices of two men who’d been dead for 12 years? Or was it something else? An acoustic trick, a psychological phenomenon, a convergence of circumstances so rare that science hasn’t yet found a name for it.

The recording exists, you can’t argue with that.

4 minutes and 17 seconds of audio, analyzed by experts, verified as authentic, containing what multiple specialists agree sounds like human speech.

words, phrases, help us, please, we’re lost.

The voices are real, but their origin remains unexplained.

Some people have tried to dismiss the entire incident.

They point to the psychological theories, griefinduced hallucinations, pattern-seeking behavior, the power of suggestion.

They heard what they expected to hear, skeptics say, nothing more.

But this explanation requires ignoring the recording, ignoring the testimony of three trained scientists, ignoring the fact that the audio analysis showed vocal patterns consistent with Ethan and Dylan themselves.

It requires believing that three people simultaneously hallucinated the same specific phrases in the same voices at the same time.

That seems to many more impossible than the alternative.

Others have embraced supernatural explanations.

The story has become fodder for paranormal enthusiasts who see it as proof of ghosts, spirits, or some form of consciousness that survives death.

But this interpretation, too, requires a leap that the evidence doesn’t support.

Ethan and Dylan weren’t the victims of violence or tragedy in the traditional sense.

They were experienced hikers who made reasonable decisions based on the information they had.

They got unlucky, trapped by an unpredictable rockfall in a place where no one could hear their cries for help.

If their voices somehow persisted in that canyon, why them? Why not the dozens of others who’ve died in Utah’s wilderness? What made their deaths different? Dr.

Um, Raone Delgado, the audio forensics expert, has said repeatedly that he doesn’t believe in the paranormal, but in a private conversation recorded for a podcast in late 2026, he admitted something that stayed with everyone who heard it.

I’ve analyzed thousands of audio recordings in my career.

Hoaxes, frauds, genuine evidence, you name it.

I can usually tell within minutes what I’m dealing with, but this recording, it’s different.

The voices are too clear, too specific, too consistent with the known vocal patterns of the deceased.

If it’s a hoax, it’s the most sophisticated one I’ve ever encountered.

And if it’s real, if those are somehow the actual voices of Ethan Cross and Dylan Mercer, then we need to fundamentally rethink what we understand about sound, time, and maybe even consciousness itself.

The scientific community remains divided.

Some researchers continue to investigate acoustic anomalies in canyon systems, hoping to find a natural explanation that doesn’t require abandoning established physics.

Others have quietly moved on, uncomfortable with a phenomenon that resists categorization.

And still others have begun to wonder whether there are aspects of reality, particularly in places as ancient and isolated as the Utah canyons, that modern science simply hasn’t developed the tools to measure yet.

Connor Mercer has found a kind of peace with not knowing.

“I used to need answers,” he told a journalist in 2027.

“I needed to understand exactly what happened, how it happened, why it happened, but I’ve realized that some questions don’t have answers, or at least not answers we can reach from where we stand.

What matters is that we found Dylan.

We brought him home and somewhere in some way I don’t fully understand he and Ethan are at rest now.

Linda Cross passed away in January 2028 at the age of 76.

Her obituary mentioned that she was preceded in death by her son Ethan and that she’d spent the final years of her life advocating for improved safety measures in national parks and wilderness areas.

At her funeral, Connor read a letter Linda had written but never sent to the sheriff’s office.

In it, she wrote, “I don’t know if my son’s voice truly echoed through that canyon after his death.

I don’t know if the universe is stranger and more mysterious than we believe, or if grief sometimes creates experiences that feel real because we need them to be.

What I do know is this.

For 12 years, I called out to my son in my heart, and he never answered.

Maybe just once, the canyon answered for him.

Maybe that’s all I’ll ever get.

And maybe that’s enough.

There are people who still camp in the robbers Roost area, though it’s become more popular since the story broke.

Some go hoping to hear something themselves, though most leave disappointed.

The canyon is silent more often than not.

Sarah Ortiz has said she’ll never return, and she’s asked repeatedly that people respect the site, not as a tourist attraction or a paranormal hotspot, but as the place where two young men lost their lives.

The Bureau of Land Management has placed a small memorial plaque near the trail head, though not at the site itself to preserve its remoteness.

The plaque reads, “In memory of Ethan Cross and Dylan Mercer, who loved these canyons and lost their lives here in April 2013, may all who enter this wilderness do so with respect, preparation, and humility before nature’s power.” But the real memorial isn’t made of bronze.

It lives in the questions that still haunt anyone who learns this story.

Questions about what happens to the energy of a voice after it’s spoken.

About whether certain places can hold memories in ways we don’t understand.

About the line between science and mystery.

Between what we can explain and what we can only witness.

Ethan Cross and Dylan Mercer went into the Utah desert as young men full of life, seeking adventure and beauty in one of the most remote places on Earth.

They died there alone and afraid.

Their voices swallowed by stone and silence.

For 12 years, they were lost.

Not just their bodies, but their story, their final moments, the desperate calls for help that no one heard until impossibly someone did.

Whether you believe Sarah Ortiz heard the actual voices of two dead men or whether you think there’s a rational explanation we simply haven’t found yet, the fact remains something happened in that canyon.

Something that three trained scientists experienced, recorded, and couldn’t explain.

Something that brought closure to families who’ waited more than a decade for answers.

Something that reminds us in an age of GPS and satellite phones and instant communication that there are still places on Earth where the rules we take for granted might not apply.

Where the boundary between past and present might be thinner than we think.

Where voices once raised in desperation might echo across years we thought were safely separated.

The canyons of southern Utah are still there, still silent, still holding secrets we may never fully understand.

And somewhere in those red rock walls carved by wind and water and time itself, the story of Ethan Cross and Dylan Mercer remains written, a reminder that some mysteries aren’t meant to be solved, only remembered.

What do you think happened that night in September 2025? Do you believe Sarah Ortiz truly heard the voices of Ethan and Dylan 12 years after their deaths, or is there a rational explanation we haven’t considered yet? Share your thoughts in the comments below.

I read every single uh one and I’d love to hear your perspective on this haunting case.

If this story moved you, if it made you think, if it reminded you that the world still holds mysteries worth exploring, please consider subscribing to this channel.

We bring you true stories of disappearances, unsolved cases, and the questions that keep us awake at night.

Hit that notification bell so you never miss an episode.

Thank you for joining me on this journey into one of the most mysterious disappearances in recent American history.

Until next time, stay curious, stay safe, and remember, the desert keeps its secrets, but sometimes, just sometimes, it whispers them Back.