The Biggest Lies Told in History: Debunking Myths From George Washington to Thanksgiving

History is often seen as a collection of facts, dates, and events carefully recorded for future generations. Yet, the saying “history is written by the victors” reveals a deeper truth: much of what we accept as historical fact is shaped by perspective, bias, and sometimes outright fabrication. From legends about iconic figures to misunderstood monuments, many stories taught in schools and popular culture are far from the truth.

In this article, we explore the biggest lies told in history—myths that have been repeated so often they seem undeniable. We’ll uncover the real stories behind Christopher Columbus, Paul Revere, George Washington, the first Thanksgiving, and more. Prepare to have your understanding of history challenged and your curiosity ignited.

The Myth of Christopher Columbus: Did He Really Discover America?

For generations, children have been taught that Christopher Columbus “discovered” America in 1492. This narrative is so ingrained that it’s often accepted without question. However, this claim is misleading and overlooks critical facts.

The Real First Settlers

Long before Columbus set sail, America was already inhabited by indigenous peoples who had migrated across the Bering Land Bridge from Asia tens of thousands of years earlier. These nomadic tribes had established thriving civilizations across the continent.

Vikings: The True Early European Visitors

Even before Columbus, Norse explorers like Leif Erikson had crossed the Atlantic and settled in parts of what is now Newfoundland, Canada, around the 11th century. Archaeological evidence supports Viking settlements in North America long before Columbus’s voyages.

Columbus’s Legacy: Colonization and Conquest

Rather than “discovering” a new world, Columbus’s expeditions marked the beginning of European colonization, conquest, and exploitation of native populations. His arrival led to dramatic and often devastating changes for indigenous peoples, including displacement, disease, and cultural erasure.

This nuanced history challenges the simplistic and glorified narrative often taught in schools.

Paul Revere’s Ride: Fact vs. Legend

The phrase “The British are coming!” is famously attributed to Paul Revere’s midnight ride, a pivotal moment in the American Revolution. But how much of this story is true?

The Reality of the Midnight Ride

Paul Revere did ride to warn American patriots about British troop movements, but he was one of many riders dispatched that night—about 40 in total. Revere was not alone; he rode with others, and his mission was part of a coordinated effort.

The Famous Quote: A Myth

The actual phrase “The British are coming!” is unlikely to have been shouted, as many colonial Americans still considered themselves British. More accurate terms like “the Regulars” were probably used.

Revere’s Ride Was Not So Smooth

Historical records reveal that Revere was detained briefly by British soldiers and did not complete the ride alone. The popularized version owes much to Henry Wadsworth Longfellow’s 1861 poem, which romanticized and simplified the event for patriotic purposes.

The Thirteen Colonies: Counting the Real Players

Everyone learns about the thirteen original American colonies, but did you know that Delaware was not always counted as a separate colony?

Delaware’s Status Before 1776

Before the Revolutionary War, Delaware was considered a lower county of Pennsylvania and was even part of Maryland territory at times. It was not declared an independent state until 1776.

What This Means for History

If your history lessons refer to the thirteen colonies before 1776, they may be oversimplifying or misrepresenting the political realities of the time. Understanding these nuances gives a clearer picture of colonial America.

The George Washington Cherry Tree Legend: A Fabricated Tale

One of the most enduring legends about George Washington is that as a young boy, he chopped down his father’s cherry tree and confessed, saying, “I cannot tell a lie.” This story is a cornerstone of American folklore, but it’s entirely fictional.

Origins of the Myth

The tale was invented by Mason Locke Weems, an early biographer of Washington. Weems wanted to present Washington as a moral exemplar for young Americans, emphasizing honesty and integrity.

Why the Story Endures

Though false, the cherry tree story endures because it conveys values admired in American culture. It’s a good story, but not a historical fact.

The Crossing of the Delaware: More Myth Than Reality?

The iconic painting of George Washington crossing the Delaware River is a powerful symbol of American bravery during the Revolutionary War. But how accurate is this depiction?

Artistic License in the Painting

Painted by German artist Emanuel Leutze in 1851, the artwork shows Washington standing heroically on a small boat amidst ice floes. In reality, the crossing involved large transport boats called Durham boats, about 40 feet long, without seats.

Historical Inaccuracies

The ice in the Delaware River tends to form large solid sheets, not the small chunks shown.

The American flag depicted was not used until 1777, a year after the crossing.

James Monroe, shown holding the flag, was likely not in the same boat as Washington.

Despite these inaccuracies, the painting remains a beloved symbol of determination and patriotism.

Van Gogh and the Ear Incident: A Different Story

The story that Vincent van Gogh cut off his own ear and mailed it to his lover is widely known but oversimplified.

What Really Happened?

Recent research suggests that Van Gogh’s ear injury may have resulted from a scuffle with a friend involving a sword, rather than a deliberate act of self-mutilation. Van Gogh was protective of his friend and chose not to report the incident.

The Myth of Madness

While Van Gogh struggled with mental health, the popular narrative of him as a “madman” who impulsively severed his ear is more complex than often portrayed.

The Sphinx’s Missing Nose: Debunking the Napoleon Myth

A common myth claims that Napoleon’s troops shot off the Great Sphinx’s nose during their Egyptian campaign. This is false.

What Really Happened?

Historical records show the nose was missing centuries before Napoleon’s birth. It likely eroded naturally or was deliberately destroyed by Muslim iconoclasts in the 14th century who opposed idol worship.

Preservation Efforts

Napoleon was actually fascinated by Egyptian antiquities and sought to preserve them, contradicting the myth of his destructive actions.

Viking Horned Helmets: A Modern Misconception

The image of Vikings wearing horned helmets is iconic but historically inaccurate.

The Origin of the Myth

This portrayal began in the 19th century, popularized by Scandinavian artists like Carl Emil Doepler. Actual Viking helmets were practical and lacked horns.

The Real Horned Helmets

Horned helmets did exist but date back to the Bronze Age and were used in religious ceremonies, not battle.

Stonehenge: The Restored Monument

Stonehenge is often believed to be a perfectly preserved ancient monument standing unchanged for 5,000 years. This is not true.

Restoration and Changes

Most of the stones visible today have been moved or restored, especially during the 20th century. Some stones are even set in concrete to stabilize the structure.

What This Means

While Stonehenge is undeniably ancient and significant, its current appearance is partly shaped by modern restoration efforts.

The First Thanksgiving: A Celebration Reconsidered

The traditional story of Thanksgiving as a friendly feast between Pilgrims and Native Americans is heavily romanticized.

The Historical Reality

Thanksgiving was celebrated after violent conflicts and retaliations between European settlers and Native Americans. The feast itself was not the harmonious event often depicted.

What Was Really Eaten?

Surprisingly, the Pilgrims likely did not eat turkey at the first Thanksgiving. The menu included seafood, venison, and local crops.

The Emotional Core: Why These Myths Persist

The Power of Storytelling

Humans are naturally drawn to stories that inspire, simplify, or symbolize ideals. Myths like Washington’s cherry tree or Paul Revere’s ride serve as moral lessons and cultural touchstones.

National Identity and Pride

Many myths reinforce national pride and identity, making them resistant to correction despite historical inaccuracies.

The Importance of Critical Thinking

Understanding the truth behind these myths encourages critical thinking and a more nuanced appreciation of history.

How to Approach History with a Balanced Perspective

Questioning Sources

Always consider the origin of historical narratives. Are they based on primary sources, or are they romanticized retellings?

Embracing Complexity

History is rarely black and white. Embrace the complexities and contradictions to gain a fuller understanding.

Celebrating Truth

While myths can be entertaining, honoring factual history respects those who lived it and provides lessons for the future.

Conclusion: Debunking Myths to Understand Our Past Better

History is a tapestry woven from facts, interpretations, and sometimes fabrications. The biggest lies told in history—from Columbus’s “discovery” to the first Thanksgiving—remind us that what we learn is often shaped by who tells the story.

By challenging these myths and seeking truth, we deepen our connection to the past and enrich our understanding of the present. So next time you hear a familiar historical tale, remember to ask: Is it fact, or just a story we want to believe?

Video