It’s not often men make a fashion faux pas. Male stars tend to get their suit game on lock and just stick with that! But Jimmy Kimmel somehow screwed up at his pal Justin Theroux‘s wedding!

If you hadn’t heard, the Leftovers star quietly got married over the weekend to his actress girlfriend Nicole Brydon Bloom. We guess the age difference didn’t end up making a difference? Anyhoo, congrats!

But now that it’s all done and can’t be crashed by paparazzi or anyone, Justin and Nicole decided to spill all about the star-studded ceremony to Vogue. The A-list included Jimmy, Paul Rudd, Ben Stiller and Christine Taylor, Beanie Feldstein, Tan France. Pal Victoria Beckham designed Nicole’s custom dress after a couple’s weekend!

But speaking of fashion, that was the issue with guest Jimmy Kimmel. The late night host was one of the groomsmen — but showed up in the wrong-colored suit! In pics of the wedding party, they had to shove him in the back! Oh no! Justin quipped:

“It’s absurd because he’s on TV every night wearing exactly what I wanted him to wear.”

Ha! He made the mistake of overthinking, we guess! LOLz! You can see what he decided on instead of a slick black suit in the sixth slide — plus many more amazing pics from the nuptials (below)!